Sunday, December 1, 2019

Joseph Jungmann and Henk Jan de Jonge on the Early Christian View of the Eucharist



On the Eucharist in general in the opening two centuries, Jungmann (in his seminal study of the original and development of the Mass) wrote:

. . . before Irenaeus . . . no offering was recognized in the Church except that which consisted in thanksgiving . . ."God does not demand an offering of victim or drink, nor of any visible things" [Aristides, Apology, 1]. He requires "not blood-oblations and drink, not the order of flowers or of incense, since He is the perfect perfume, without want or blemish." The highest sacrifice one can offer Him is to acknowledge Him and tender Him our spiritual service [Athenagoras, Legatio, c. 13]. The only honor worthy of Him is to put His gifts to use for ourselves and for the poor, and to "be thankful and by our spirit send heavenward songs of praise and hymns of glory for our creation . . ." [Justin Martyr, Apology, 1.13]. For this reason, the apologists explained, the Christians had no altar and no temple" [Minucius Felix, Octavius, c. 32, 1]. (Joseph A. Jungmann, The Mass of the Roman Rite, Volume 1 [trans. Francis A. Brunner; Christian Classics, 2012], 24-25).

On the Eucharistic theology of the Didache (variously dated between AD 50-100) specifically, Henk Jan de Jonge wrote:

The congregation thanked God not only for material food and drink, but also for spiritual food and drink: knowledge, faith, immortality, and eternal life. It is not stated in these prayers of thanks that the bread and wine stand for Christ’s body and blood. The Didache therefore did not interpret them as representations of his body and blood, and consequently it does not see the meal as a way of becoming one with Christ. It does, however, regard eating and drinking them as an anticipated, proleptic participation in a future salvation, namely the coming kingdom of God. According to 9:2 the wine represents the vine of king David, God’s servant; according to 9:3 the bread symbolizes the unity of the church gathered into God’s kingdom” (Henk Jan de Jonge, The Community Supper according to Paul and the Didache: Their Affinity and Historical Development, eds. Jan Krans, L. J. Lietaert Peerbolte, Peter-Ben Smit, Arie W. Zwiep, Paul, John, and Apocalyptic Eschatology, [BRILL, 2013], p. 34).

For a discussion of commonly cited proof-texts from the Didache, writings of Ignatius, Origen, and others, see: