Wednesday, June 17, 2020

Kenton L. Sparks on Deuteronomy 6:4 being an Affirmation of Mono-Yahwism, not Monotheism Per Se

 

The Formula ‘Yahweh, Your God’ (יהוה אלהיך). It is very easy, given the common translation of יהוה אלהך as ‘the Lord your God’, to overlook the fact that repetition of this phrase in Deuteronomy 5-11 served the role of emphasizing the personal name of the deity, Yahweh, and his claim to Israel’s sole allegiance. In this respect, the traditional translation does grave injustice to the intent of the Deuteronomistic legislation, since the central issue in Deuteronomy, as it was in Hosea, was the competition between the God Yahweh and other deities, such as Baal (We should note the work of B. Halpern, who concludes, correctly, I think, that in the seventh century the term Baal served a collective function and referred, polemically speaking, to all foreign deities [“The Baal [and the Asherah] in seventh-century Judah: Yhwh’s Retainers Retired,” in Konsequente Traditionsgeschichte: Festschrift für Klaus Baltzer zum 65. Geburtsag [ed. R. Bartelmus: OBO 126; Gōttingen: Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht, 1993], 115-54). The Deuteronomic movement was attempting to place any expressions of what it viewed as religious pluralism with mono-Yahwism, and many themes in Deuteronomy turn out to be ancillary to this main theme. So, for instance, although it is common to focus on the notion of covenant and its importance in Deuteronomy—and it was, no doubt important—the primary function of the covenant was to promote the Deuteronomic preference for an exclusive relationship with Yahweh. And many phrases used in the book, such as the concept of Israel as a “holy people” and the claim that the people were “set apart” by Yahweh from among “all the peoples on the ace of the earth,” were designed to emphasize this special and therefore exclusive kind of relationship Israel ought to have with its deity. This is not to overlook the obvious fact that beyond the struggle of Yahwism against non-Yahwism there was also a struggle between “pure” Yahwism . . . (Kenton L. Sparks, Ethnicity and Identity in Ancient Israel: Prolegomena to the Study of Ethnic Sentiments and their Expression in the Hebrew Bible [Winona Lake, Ind.: Eisenbrauns, 1998], 229-30)

 

Further Reading 


Refuting Jeff Durbin on "Mormonism" (exegetes Isa 43:10; 44:6, 8 and other relevant texts; cf. C.J. Labuschagne on the language of "incomparability" in the Old Testament and Literature of Surrounding Cultures)