Timothy Anders Vs Suan Sonna: Should We Hold to Sola Scriptura? EP 144
Tonight, there was a debate between Timothy Anders (Protestant) and Suan Sonna (Catholic) on the topic of Sola Scriptura. I asked the following question to Anders at the 2:03:33 mark:
How could S[ola]S[criptura] be exegeted from any OT/NT text when they were written during a time of special revelation? For SS to be the rule of faith, there must first be *tota* scriptura.
Anders, notwithstanding being a Protestant, admitted that (1) sola scriptura was never a standard, during the OT-period or the NT-era and (2) it is a post-apostolic tradition. He also admitted that (3) Sola Scriptura cannot be taught during the NT-era as it was a time of special revelation.
In other words, the Bible cannot be used, exegetically, to support sola scriptura.
For more, see the discussion under "Falling at the First Hurdle: Why Sola Scriptura is an exegetical impossibility" at Not By Scripture Alone: A Latter-day Saint Refutation of Sola Scriptura.