Friday, September 17, 2021

John Joy on the Schematization of the Distinction between the Ordinary and Extraordinary Magisterium in Catholicism

 

 

In the context of the classification of doctrine, then, the distinction between the ordinary and extraordinary magisterium is typically schematized as follows:

 

I. Catholic Dogma (de fide credenda)

a. Defined by Extraordinary Magisterium

i. By the Pope Speaking ex cathedra

ii. By an Ecumenical Council

b. Taught by Ordinary and Universal Magisterium

II. Definitive Catholic Doctrine (de fide tenenda)

a. Defined by Extraordinary Magisterium

i. By the Pope speaking ex cathedra

ii. By an Ecumenical Council

b. Taught by Ordinary and Universal Magisterium

III. Authentic Catholic Doctrine

a. Taught by Ordinary Magisterium of People

b. Taught by Ordinary Magisterium of Bishops (John Joy, On the Ordinary and Extraordinary magisterium from Joseph Kleutgen to the Second Vatican Council [Studia Oecumenica Friburgensia 84; Münster: Ashendorff Verlag, 2017], 9)

 

Further Reading


John P. Joy on Theological Notations in Catholicism