Monday, March 28, 2022

Bede's Interpretation of Romans 15:4

  

For whatever was written in former days was written for our instruction, so that by steadfastness and by the encouragement of the scriptures we might have hope. (Rom 15:4 NRSV)

 

In his Prologue to his On the Temple, Bede (d. 735), using Rom 15:4, wrote the following:

 

Prol. 1 The vessel of election and teacher of the gentiles exhorts us to read the word of God, affirming truthfully that whatever was written in former days was written for us instruction so that by steadfastness and the encouragement of the scriptures we might have hope. In this passage he quite rightly declares that to secure the hope of heavenly goods we must have patience, and contemplate the consolation of the scriptures; patience, that is, to bear with an attitude of humble submission the adversities that befall us as punishments imposed by a just judge and compassionate father whether for the enhancement of our virtue and increase of merit, should we be punished, even though upright and innocent, or for the correction and our conduct should we be enmeshed in vice; on the other hand, we need the consolation of the scriptures to that by frequent meditation on them we may call to mind how much dark affliction those eminent Fathers of the Church and the bright luminaries of the Church have often borne even during this life, how much glory they have enjoyed with their master in the life to come through the merits of their fidelity and patience, and how much unfailing praise and fame they have left behind among the faithful even in this life; as scripture says, the memory of the righteous is a blessing, and again, Their bodies were buried in peace and their name lives to all generations, and the apostle James, Behold, we call those happy who were steadfast. You have heard of the steadfastness of Job, and you have seen the purpose of the Lord. Now it is not for nothing that, after mentioning the afflictions of the just, he added: and you have seen the purpose of the Lord, because even he who lived his life here below without fault, did not depart from this life without chastisement, and he who appeared in the world to heal the sick and raise the dead, chose to return from the world in the weakness of death to set us an example of patience. Hence after saying, Our God is a God of salvation, the psalmist directly added in wonder or rather in astonishment, and the Lord belongs escape from death. (Bede: On the Temple [trans. Seán Connolly; Translated Texts for Historians; Liverpool: Liverpool University Press, 1995], 1-2)

 

In the words of the translator, Seán Connolly, for Bede, in light of Bede’s interpretation of Rom 15:4,

 

Although the Temple had long since been superseded by the Church and indeed physically destroyed, like the earlier Tabernacle its original construction had been divinely ordered and planned . . . Even circumstantial details are therefore of importance. (Ibid., xxxi).

 

This is further explicated in 5.2:

 

Now we have said that the Synagogue could be denoted by the tabernacle which Moses and the children of Israel built in the desert, but the Church of the gentiles by the temple which Solomon and the children of Israel erected with the help of the proselytes and gentiles. The worship and religion of the tabernacle lasted four hundred and eighty years and then work began on the building of the temple because the writing of the Old Testament overflows with such perfection that, if one understands it properly, it contains in itself all the mysteries of the New Testament. Besides, a great many of the patriarchs of the Old Testament attained such a peak of perfection by the way they lived that they are not in any way to be considered inferior to the apostles or apostolic men. The tabernacle remained among the people of God for four hundred and eighty years, until the construction of the temple, i.e. for a hundred and twenty years multiplied by four, because from the time the Law was given until the Lord’s incarnation and the time of the revelation of grace there was no lack of people who were grounded in the Law and observed evangelical perfection in all things in outlook and action; and there was no lack of scripture to intimate by its prophetic words the grace of the New Testament in the Old. But the fact that it was in the fourth year of Solomon’s reign that work began on the house of the Lord can be applied mystically to the fact that after the completion of the dispensation of the Lord’s incarnation which was treated in the four books of the Gospel, the construction of the holy Church began when the Holy Spirit was sent from heaven. And the fact that it was begun in the second month can be applied to the election of the gentiles that undertook the creator’s building in the second place after Israel. Hence also the second month was granted for celebrating the Pasch to those who, because they were unclean in soul or lived at a distance, was unable to attend the Pasch in the first month. This obviously refers to us who, because we are unclean on account of the death of our soul and still live far from the people of God, cannot hold the first Pasch which was celebrated with the flesh and blood of a lamb. But we celebrate today the second Pasch which is enacted with the body and blood of our redeemer by whom we were sought and have been cleansed. (Ibid., 18-19)

 

So, for Bede, Rom 15:4 is not, as some Protestants understand it, an affirmation of Sola Scriptura; instead, it means that the Old Testament contains lessons, via typology, for the Church age.

 

On Rom 15:4 and whether it does teach Sola Scriptura (spoiler: it doesn’t), see:

 

Not By Scripture Alone: A Latter-day Saint Refutation of Sola Scriptura