Tuesday, May 24, 2022

Does the Book of Jubilees (2nd Century BC) support a Figurative Interpretation of the Millennium?

 According to G. K. Beale, the 2nd century BC text Jubilees supports a figurative interpretation of the then-future millennial age (giving support to amillennialism, not pre-millennialism):

 

Jubilees understands that the ideal life of the probationary period (“day”) in Eden should have been one thousand years (so also Midr. Rab. Gen. 19.8; Midr. Rab. Num. 5.4; Midr. Ps. 25.8 on the basis of Psalm 90). The Jubilees text concludes that the future messianic reign must achieve what Adam did not because Adam did not live one thousand years, because Isa. 65:22 prophesied that the messianic age will last as long as the ideal meant for the first paradise (likewise Test. Levi 18:8–13), and because of Ps. 90:4 (the Jubilees tradition of the ideal millennial span of the first paradise is reflected in Irenaeus, Adversus Haereses 5.23:2). At least in part, Jub. 23:27–30 was influenced to conceive of this millennium figuratively by the Psalm 90 formula, whereas early church fathers like Justin Martyr (Dialogue 81) used the same reasoning to formulate a literal premillennial perspective (cf. likewise Hippolytus, Commentary on Daniel 2.4–6, and possibly Methodius, Banquets of the Ten Virgins 9.1; Extracts from the Work on Things Created 9, though they may reflect a similar line of interpretation as in Barnabas 15 or perhaps Irenaeus). (G. K. Beale, The Book of Revelation: A Commentary on the Greek Text [New International Greek Testament Commentary; Grand Rapids, Mich.: Eerdmans, 1999], 1019)

 

In response, Matt Waymeyer notes that Beale

 

fails to provide evidence for the symbolic view of the millennium’s duration. A closer look at this passage, in fact, demonstrates that the “thousand years” in Jubilees 23:27 was actually intended literally. The angelic address in Jubilees 23 beings with an explanation of why Abraham lived to be only 175 years of age while his ancestors had lived far longer (vv. 1-10). According to the angel, the increase of wickedness leads to a steady decrease in life spans (vv. 11-25). In the midst of this, God’s people will lament the reality that the lives of Abraham’s forefathers extended as long as a “thousand years” but their life spans were limited to only 70 or 80 years (v. 15). But the turning point will eventually come when the children begin to seek the commandments of God and return to the path of righteousness (v. 26). As a result of this repentance, “The days will begin to become numerous and increase, and mankind as well—generation by generation and day by day until their lifetimes approach one thousand years and to more years than the number of days [had been]” (v. 27; emphasis added). In other words, the actions of the children will reverse this downward spiral of lie spans so dramatically that human ages will once again, as in the days before Abraham, approach the length of a thousand years. During this time, God’s covenant promises will be fulfilled and His chosen people will live in peace and joy as the Lord shows them mercy (vv. 28-31). In the greater context of the original prophecy, then, the “thousand years” of Jubilees 23:27 must be literal, because the overall picture is that of human life spans being restored to those of Abraham’s forefathers. The “thousand years” of Jubilees 23:27 is just as literal as the “thousand years” of Jubilees 23:15, and the amillennial view of the “thousand years” in Revelation 20 gains no support from this appeal. (Matt Waymeyer, Amillennialism and the Age to Come: A Premillennial Critique of the Two-Age Model [The Woodlands, Tex.: Kress Biblical Resources, 2016], 254-55)

 

Appendix: Jubilees chapter 23

 

The following is the translation of Jubilees 23 in O.S. Wintermute, "Jubilees (Second Century B.C.): A New Translation and Introduction," in The Old Testament Pseudepigrapha, ed. James H. Charlesworth, 2 vols. (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1985), 2:99-102:

 

The death and burial of Abraham

23 1* And he placed the two fingers of Jacob on his eyes and he blessed the God of gods. And he covered his face, and stretched out his feet and slept the eternal sleep, and he was gathered to his fathers. 2* During all of this (time) Jacob was lying on his bosom and did not know that Abraham, his grandfather, was dead. And Jacob awoke from his sleep and, behold, Abraham was cold as ice, and he said, “O father, father!” And none spoke. And he knew that he was dead.

And he rose up from his bosom and ran and told Rebecca, his mother. And Rebecca went to Isaac in the night and told him. And they went together and Jacob was also with them, and a lamp was in his hand. And when they went, they found Abraham lying dead. And Isaac fell upon his father’s face and wept and kissed him. And the sound was heard in Abraham’s house and Ishmael, his son, arose and went to Abraham, his father. And he wept for Abraham, his father, he and all of Abraham’s house, and they wept greatly. And his sons, Isaac and Ishmael, buried him in the cave of Machpelah near Sarah, his wife. And all of the men of his house and Isaac and Ishmael and all of their sons and all of the sons of Keturah wept for him forty days in their places. And the days of Abraham’s weeping were completed.

A discussion of the general decline in longevity

8* And he lived three jubilees and four weeks of years, one hundred and seventy-five years. And he completed the days of his life, being old and full of days. For the days of the lives of the ancients were nineteen jubilees. And after the Flood they began to be less than nineteen jubilees and to grow old quickly and to shorten the days of their lives due to much suffering and through the evil of their ways—except Abraham. 10 For Abraham was perfect in all of his actions with the Lord and was pleasing through righteousness all of the days of his life. And behold, he did not complete four jubilees in his life until he grew old in the presence of evil (and) his days were full.

11* And all of the generations which will arise henceforth and until the day of the great judgment will grow old quickly before they complete two jubilees, and their knowledge will forsake them because of their old age. And all of their knowledge will be removed. 12 And in those days if a man will live a jubilee and a half, they will say about him, “He prolonged his life, but the majority of his days were suffering and anxiety and affliction. And there was no peace, 13* because plague (came) upon plague, and wound upon wound, and affliction upon affliction, and evil report upon evil report, and sickness upon sickness, and every evil judgment of this sort one with another: sickness, and downfall, and sleet, and hail, and frost, and fever, and chills, and stupor, and famine, and death, and sword, and captivity, and all plagues, and suffering.”

14 And all of this will come in the evil generation which sins in the land. Pollution and fornication and contamination and abomination are their deeds. 15* Then they will say, “The days of the ancients were as many as one thousand years and good. But behold, (as for) the days of our lives, if a man should extend his life seventy years or if he is strong (for) eighty years, then these are evil. And there is not any peace in the days of this evil generation.”

The description of the future evil generation

16* And in this generation children will reproach their parents and their elders on account of sin, and on account of injustice, and on account of the words of their mouth, and on account of great evil which they will do, and on account of their forsaking the covenant which the Lord made between them and himself so that they might be careful and observe all of his commandments and his ordinances and all of his law without turning aside to the right or left. 17* For they all did evil and every mouth speaks of sin and all of their deeds (are) polluted and abominable. And all of their ways (are) contamination and pollution and corruption.

18* Behold, the land will be corrupted on account of all their deeds, and there will be no seed of the vine, and there will be no oil because their works are entirely faithless. And all of them will be destroyed together: beast, cattle, birds, and all of the fish of the sea on account of the sons of man. 19 Some of these will strive with others, youths with old men and old men with youths, the poor with the rich, the lowly with the great, and the beggar with the judge concerning the Law and the Covenant because they have forgotten the commandments and covenant and festivals and months and sabbaths and jubilees and all of the judgments. 20 And they will stand up with bow and swords and war in order to return them to “the way,” but they will not be returned until much blood is shed upon the earth by each (group). 21 And those who escape will not be turned back from their evils to the way of righteousness because they will lift themselves up for deceit and wealth so that one shall take everything of his neighbor; and they will pronounce the great name but not in truth or righteousness. And they will pollute the holy of holies with their pollution and with the corruption of their contamination.

Punishment on that generation followed by repentance and God’s blessings

22 And there will be a great plague upon the deeds of that generation from the Lord and he will give them to the sword and to judgment and to captivity and pillage and destruction. 23* And he will rouse up against them the sinners of the nations who have no mercy or grace for them and who have no regard for any persons old or young or anyone. For (they will be) cruel and powerful so that they will act more evilly than any of the sons of men.

*And they will cause turmoil in Israel and sin against Jacob;

and much blood will be shed upon the earth;

and there will be no one who will gather and no one who will bury.

24* In those days, they will cry out and call and pray

to be saved from the hand of the sinners, the gentiles,

but there will be none who will be saved,

25 and the heads of children will be white with gray hairs,

and an infant three weeks old will look aged

like one whose years (are) one hundred,

and their stature will be destroyed by affliction and torment.

26 And in those days, children will begin to search the law,

and to search the commandments

and to return to the way of righteousness.

27 And the days will begin to increase and grow longer

among those sons of men, generation by generation,

and year by year, until

their days approach a thousand years,

and to a greater number of years than days.

28* And there (will be) no old men and none who is full of days.

Because all of them will be infants and children.

29* And all of their days they will be complete

and live in peace and rejoicing

and there will be no Satan and no evil (one) who will destroy,

because all of their days will be days of blessing and healing.

30 And then the Lord will heal his servants,

and they will rise up and see great peace.

And they will drive out their enemies,

and the righteous ones will see and give praise,

and rejoice forever and ever with joy;

and they will see all of their judgments and all of their curses among their enemies.

31* And their bones will rest in the earth,

and their spirits will increase joy,

and they will know that the Lord is an executor of judgment;

but he will show mercy to hundreds and thousands,

to all who love him.

32 And you, Moses, write these words because thus it is written and set upon the heavenly tablets as a testimony for eternal generations.