Tuesday, May 24, 2022

George Reynolds and Janne M. Sjodahl vs. the Heartland Model: The Jaredites were not the Mound Builders

  

. . . Were the Jaredites the mound builders? Again we answer, We think not. The remains found in the mounds that have been opened betoken a race of builders far inferior in civilization to what Ether represents the Jaredites to have been. True, it is possible, as some have suggested, that an inferior race of later ages, may have opened these mounds and made them sepulchres for the dead, and placed therein, with the dead, the flint and quartzite arrowheads, the beads, pipes, shells, and inferior pottery and ornaments that have been there found. It is also quite supposable that the mounds scattered far and wide about the northern continent, were not all built by the same race. It is affirmed with some show of evidence that some of these mounds are known to have been built by the Shawnees and Cherokees, while others are ascribed to the Chickasaws and Winnebagos. It is also suggested that the Mandans and Minnitarees were at one time mound-building people.

 

Major J. W. Powell, director of the U. S. Bureau of Ethnology, in the Forum, says: “No fragment of evidence remains to support the figment of theory that there was an ancient race of mound builders superior in culture to the North American Indians.”

 

A lady writer (Mary Morrison) writing on this question in "Hearth and Hall," (Reprinted in the “Woman’s Exponent,” July 15th; August 1st, and August 15th, 1892) sums up the opinions of a number of intelligent investigators in the following statement:

 

"The mound-builders were formerly regarded as a race so remote from the present Indian tribes that there could be nothing between them, yet all recent theories deny this. Many Indian tribes have built burial mounds for their dead.

 

"Some of the mounds in Ohio have yielded from their deepest recesses articles of European manufacture, showing an origin not farther back than the historic period. Spanish swords and blue grass beads have been found in the mounds of Georgia and Florida . . .

 

"The annals of the Columbian epoch have been carefully studied, and it is found that some of the mounds have been constructed in historical times, while early explorers and settlers found many actually used by tribes of North American Indians; so we know that many of the Indians were builders of mounds. The contents of these mounds have been compared with the works of art of the Indian tribes before they were influenced by Europeans and both were substantially identical." (George Reynolds and Janne M. Sjodahl, Commentary on the Book of Mormon, 7 vols. [Salt Lake City: Deseret Book, 1977], 6:231-32)