Saturday, June 10, 2023

Jörg Frey on מעשי התירה in 4QMMT

  

In the MMT, the term מעשי התירה clearly points to the halakhic regulations or teachings mentioned before in part B. But it is a severe misinterpretation to limit the term (in MMT and even more so in Paul) in mere precepts, as MMT strongly presupposes that these teachings ought to be practiced by the addressee or the group he represents. The focus is on doing “what is right and good before him,” i.e. on the lawful works, so that the term should not be translated as “precepts of the law”, as it is always implied that they are precepts that the law demands to be obeyed. Paul likewise draws on ‘works’ that were apparently supposed to make a human righteous (before God, in an eschatological judgment), so that also in Paul it is implausible to limit these εργα to mere precepts or halakhot without considering the practice of those precepts as well.

 

d) This is confirmed by the fact that, only four lines later, the author phrases: “ . . . it will be reckoned to you as righteousness, in that you have done what is right and good before him” (MMT viii 17-18 [C31-32]). Again, the author stresses “doing” what is right before God, and this refers quite clearly to the “works of the law,” and precepts or halakhot as presented before. The phrase “reckoned to one as righteousness” echoes the MT of Psalm 106:31 (rather than Gen 15:6 where not the nif’al but the qal of חשב is used). It can be assumed that the subject of such a ‘reckoning’ or the one who can consider the addressee righteous (because of his practice of lawful works) is God. The addressee will “rejoice in the end” if he has accepted the teaching and practiced the works accordingly so that he will be considered righteous. Here, righteousness occurs in a clearly eschatological framework in which the human (here: the addressee) is judged by God, and the criterion of being considered righteous is the teaching and practice of lawful works, based on the adoption of the correct halakhic interpretation. (Jörg Frey, “Contextualizing Paul’s ‘Works of the Law’: 4QMMT in New Testament Scholarship,” in Interpreting and Living God’s Law at Qumran: Miqṣat Ma’aśe Ha-Torah Some of the Works of the Torah (4QMMT), ed. Reinhard G. Kratz [Scriptura Antiquitatis Poserioris ad Ethicam Religionemque Pertinentía 37; Tübingen: Mohr Siebeck, 2020], 211)