Monday, November 13, 2023

Slavian (5th c.) vs. Eternal Security

  

(16) Perhaps to any of you who lack faith, these statement seem to be either without validity or clarity. The Lord Himself most clearly teaches in the Gospel that a Christian loses nothing from his good works when He said: 'Whosoever shall give to drink to one of these least ones a cup of cold water only, in the name of a disciple, Amen I say to you, he shall not lose his reward.' What could be said more clearly? he said that one would receive a reward in the next world for a thing that was valueless in the present world. He attached so much honor to worshipping God that faith will give merit in heaven to that which is worthless in this life.

 

Lest anyone delude himself by the false hope that those who have much can buy much for little, He implied that the reward for even a cup of cold water would not be lost. He showed clearly thereby not that much will be received for having given little, but only that any work done with faith would not go unrecompensed.

 

You have the undoubted surety of future recompense. You have a most suitable guarantee that good works are acceptable to Him. You have Him whose assurance, mercy, and goodness are so great that he not only pays what He promised as a debt, but even points out something by which He makes Himself indebted to you. He who said that He would give Himself as a reward for a cup of cold water not only wishes to pay for what He had received, but also points out the reward which He is paying. Tender and full of mercy and desirous of rewarding not only the liberality of the rich, but even the tiny kindnesses of the poor, He points out also how we can lend at interest and make God indebted to us, even though we have nothing whatsoever.

 

(17) To any of you who are rich, perhaps this charity seems unworthy of your wealth, and you wish to hear some pledge of the Holy Promise particularly pertinent to you. In the first place, you have that saying which God spoke to that rich man in the Gospel: 'Go, sell all your goods, and you will have treasure in Heaven.' Next, that saying wherein He orders with a general prohibitory command: 'Do not lay up for yourselves treasures on earth, but lay up for yourselves treasures in Heaven.'

 

Lastly, He spoke these words with which He invited all possessors of worldly goods to the duty of abundant alms with the hope of eternal reward, because every man who for the honor and love of God put aside either his house, or field, or any other wealth whatsoever as alms would receive a hundred-fold in the next world. 'But moreover,' He says, 'he will possess eternal life.' What better answer could He, who promised that He would pay back a hundredfold interest to those who loaned Him wealth, give to them who believe in Him?

 

Not only this, but He said: 'he will possess life eternal.' This is much more than the actual hundredfold return, because what anybody receives a hundredfold he will possess forever. Eternal life will not be a perishable and transitory possession, nor will it be like earthly riches of passing semblance, or perishable in the manner of vanishing dreams. Whatever will be given by God will be immortal and whatever has been received will remain without end. And therefore, as I said, he who so receives more than a hundredfold, because he wins the prize of the hundredfold and that is an everlasting hundredfold.

 

(18) Since this is the case and since he who believes in God will doubtless receive great rewards in return, how can you think that riches given by you to God will not profit you after death? God has promised you these riches—not only their use, but also the fullest measure of return from them? Or, perhaps you do not wish to receive these great return from them. Or, perhaps you do not wish to receive these great returns? But it does not stand to reason that you do not wish to receive them.

 

There is no one among men who chooses to be sad when he can be happy; there is nobody alive who, when he can have the delights of the greatest good, wishes to suffer the punishment of the greatest evil. There is no one at all—not even you. Unless, perhaps, your nature is abnormal and you differ from the human race in that you alone do not wish yourself well, you alone flee from happiness, you alone delight in punishment.

 

If this is not your nature, when you are dying and have arrived at the last moments of life, why do you not render the obligation of the highest sacrifice with the whole of your wealth, so that, if you can deserve it from God, you may be eternally rich and happy? if, on the contrary, you cannot do this, act so that you may merit not to be truly wretched, that you may not burn, that you may not suffer, that you may not be destroyed in the exterior darkness, and that you may not burn in everlasting flames.

 

As I have said, what reason is there that you do not do these things? What reason is there that you do not purchase eternal goods? What reason is there that you do not fear do not think you are to be judged by God or you do not fully eternal evils? What indeed, except as I have said before, you believe that you will arise from the dead? If you did believe, would you not flee from that immeasurable evil of the future judgment and avoid the torments of eternal punishments?

 

You do not believe; you do not believe; though you assert otherwise by word and profession, still you do not believe. Your speech and profession make a display of your faith, but your life and death make public your lack of faith. Convince me otherwise. I want to be convinced. I do not ask that you prove to me your belief by acts of your past life. I am content with the one proof furnished by your last moments.

 

Behold, behold, you are on the point of death. You are about to depart from the home of your body, not knowing where you will go, where you are to be taken. You do not know to what punishment, to what foulness, you are being dragged. You, to whom only one thing remains in the midst of your last moments, to you there is given one slight hope as an asylum for fleeing eternal fire. Offer at least one your own behalf what you have of your substance, because you do not have anything else you can offer to God. You are unmindful of yourself, forgetful of your own salvation. You are thinking about new legatees, you are longing to enrich your heir.

 

When you act as you do, do you say that you believe in the judgment of God? You who are being judged, do you consult your own little interests in the midst of your last moments? Do you say that you believe that you are occupied with the salvation of your soul, to whom it almost does not matter whom you favor provided you injure yourself? Do you say that you believe in the future judgment, you with whom there is nobody less and more despised than the Judge Himself? You scorn Him so much, you despise Him so much, that you do not consult your own interest with Him as long as you regard His commands with contempt.

 

If I am lying, refute or convince me. Behold, your Judge, who is about to judge you, cries out to you, who are dying, that you are not to love anyone more than yourself when you are handing out your property and resources; that you, when you are dying, are not to consult the interest of your substance more than of yourself; that you are not to think someone more dear and more closely related to you than your own soul. The Saviour says: 'What shall it profit a man if he gain the whole world and suffer the loss of his soul? or what will a man give in exchange for his soul?'

 

This means: what will it profit you, O most unhappy man, if you possess the whole world or leave it to your near relatives, if you suffer the loss of your salvation and soul? Damnation of the soul takes everything completely with it. Neither can a man possess anything whatsoever, who loses himself with the loss of his soul. The Saviour says: 'Or what shall a man give in exchange for his soul?' This means: O man, do not look to money or possessions and do not hesitate, when you are dying, to offer as much as you can of your property and wealth in exchange for your hope. Whatever you give on your own behalf is too little to offer. Whatsoever you offer on your own behalf is a small price, because, in comparison, your soul is more valuable than all riches. Therefore, have no hesitation in giving on your own behalf, because, if you lose yourself, you lose everything in yourself. But if you gain yourself, you shall possess all things with and in yourself. (Salvian, The Four Books of Timothy to the Church, Book 3, 16-18, in Salvian: The Writings of Salvian the Presbyter [trans. Jeremiah F. O’Sullivan; The Fathers of the Church 3; Washington D. C.: The Catholic University of America Press, 1947], 345-49)