Tuesday, May 7, 2024

Joan Cecelia Campbell's Defense of the Plural Reading in John 1:13

  

[according to J. Galot] Because verse twelve mentions humans becoming children of God, a plural reading in verse thirteen would introduce a tautology. Thus, argues Galot, the singular provides a better development of the thought; the Word gives humans the authority to become children of God, because the Word has been born of God.

 

While Galot’s examination of the evidence is comprehensive and persuasive, it is not clear how a tautology is problematic in the gospel’s prologue, which is replete with repetition. Furthermore, not a single ancient Greek manuscript attests to the singular reading: the vast majority of witnesses, including the Bodmer papyri, support the plural, and with regard to internal criteria, it is much easier to imagine a scribal alternation intended to promote the virginal conception than to envision such evidence being later eliminated. (Joan Cecelia Campbell, Kinship Relations in the Gospel of John [The Catholic Biblical Quarterly Monograph Series 42; Washington, D.C.: The Catholic Biblical Association of America, 2007], 50-51)