Thursday, November 14, 2024

Jonathan Williams on the Various Terms used for "Hardening" in Exodus

  

The Hebrew text uses three words that are translated “harden.” The first word is kavad כַּבד, which means “to make heavy, dull, and unresponsive.” This is used in 8:15, 32; 9:7, 34, and 10:1. In three of the verses Pharaoh hardened or made his heart full (8:15, 32; 9:34). In one verse God does it (10:1). In another it is unclear who is doing the hardening (9:7). In 9:34, it is Pharaoh and his servants hardening their hearts. This is the same word used in Isaiah 6:10 when God tells the prophet to render the ears of the people of Israel “dull,” i.e., to make them unable to hear. The “making heavy or dull” was a consequence of Israel’s disobedience to the Lord, and in the time of Isaiah, it led to refining judgment. It was the same for Pharaoh and his court. God’s hardening was a consequence for their sin against God.

 

The second Hebrew word is qashah קָשָׁה. It has many meanings in Hebrew including to make difficult, to make hard, severe, stiff, burdensome, and stubborn. This is used in Exodus 7:3 where God says he will harden Pharaoh’s heart so that he may multiply his wonders in the land of Egypt.

 

The final and the one most frequently used is chazaq חָזַק and it means “to strengthen.” We find this in 4:21; 7:13, 22; 8:19; 9:2, 12, 35; 10:20, 27; 11:10; 12:33; 14:4, 8, 17. The verses in bold indicate that God is doing the strengthening/hardening. The other verses are ambiguous Eight times God says he strengthened Pharaoh’s heart. The context of these is also important. In 9:8-12 we read of the plague of boils. The narrative tells us that the magicians of Egypt were not able to duplicate this miracle, and we find an interesting comment in 9:12 that Pharaoh refused to listen to his magicians. They were telling Pharaoh, dependent upon his magicians, would normally acquiesce and listen, but God would not allow him to listen to them. He hardened, i.e., he strengthened Pharoh’s resolve to continue to stand in his struggle to keep the Hebrews as his slaves.

 

In 10:12-20, we read about the plague of locusts. In 10:16 we find Pharaoh hurriedly calling Moses and Aaron, confessing that he has sinned against God and them, asking for forgiveness, and asking for prayer for the locusts to be removed. God removed the locusts, but he also strengthened Pharaoh’s heart so that he would change his mind and not allow the people to go. Why? God had more that he wanted to show.

 

In 10:21-29 we read about the plague of darkness and Pharaoh telling the Israelites to leave and serve the Lord but they must leave their cattle in Egypt. Moses replied that the cattle must come with them, and God hardened Pharaoh’s heart not to let them go. God had more that he wanted to show.

 

In 11:1-10, Moses announced the last plague of darkness and Pharaoh telling the Israelites to leave and serve the Lord, but they must leave their cattle in Egypt. Moses replied that the cattle must come with them, and God hardened Pharaoh’s heart not to let them go. God had more that he wanted to show.

 

In 11:1-10, Moses announced the last plague, the death of the firstborn. He told Pharaoh that all the people would bow to Moses, and they would tell the Israelites to leave. But God hardened Pharaoh’s heart not to yield to the threat of this last plague.

 

Finally, in 14:4, 8, and 17, God hardened Pharaoh’s heart (and the hearts of his army—see verse 17) so that they chased after the Hebrews and were then engulfed in the waters of the sea.

 

What is our purpose in examining these Exodus narratives? It is to understand the plan behind the hardening work of God. The stories are about God revealing his glory to the nations. The stories show that God raised up Pharaoh, i.e., he gave him strength to withstand all the plagues so that God could proclaim his name throughout the earth. In this way, the nations would see that the God of Israel was the true God. This is the story Paul invoked when he quoted Exodus 9:16. Paul was showing that just as God had mercy upon his sinful people and advanced his plans in the world through them, he could also use stubborn pagan rulers, give them strength to stand against him, and advance his plan of proclaiming his name to the world. It was all to advance his covenant plan for the nations. (Jonathan Williams, Romans 9 and the Story Paul was Telling [2023], 60-62)

 

To Support this Blog:

 

Patreon

Paypal

Venmo

Amazon Wishlist

Email for Amazon Gift card: ScripturalMormonism@gmail.com