Friday, January 30, 2026

Scott Brazil on Luke 13:34 (cf. Matthew 23:37)

  

Luke 13:34

 

The wording of Jesus’s lament in Luke 13:34 is virtually the same as that in Matthew 23:37. Jesus’s central allusion to YHWH-texts is found in his expressed desire to gather Jerusalem’s children as a hen gathers her brood under her wings. Theoretically, this claim could have been expressed by a mere leader—a prophet, priest, or king—of Israel, except that the Lukan context demands understanding Jesus’s words as the personal desire of YHWH.

 

First, YHWH is the only OT figure who compared his relationship to Israel as that of a mother bird to her young. He introduced the figure to describe himself bearing the Israelites on eagles’ wings during the Exodus (Exod 19:4)—a thought repeated in the Song of Moses (Deut 32:11) and serving as inspiration for Israel’s worship of YHWH who provided refuge in the shelter of his wings (cf. Pss 17:8; 36:7; 57:1; 61:4; 63:7; 91:4). Second, Jesus claimed that his desire to gather his people (“Jerusalem”) to himself (“under her wings”) was a longstanding concern with repeated attempts (“How often . . .!”). On the surface, Jesus’s expression of frequency does not make sense of the Lukan narrative, in which no visit of Jesus to Jerusalem as an adult has yet been recorded.  However, in the Lukan metanarrative, which has been emphasizing the visitation of YHWH to Israel (Luke 1:68, 78; 7:16; cf. 19:44) in the preexistent “Lord” Jesus (1:17, 43, 76; 2:11; 3:4–6; 7:26–27), Jesus’s claim only verifies the big picture: YHWH has come again to his people in Jesus, yet they have largely refused to come under his protection.

 

Third, Jesus’s lament echoes the laments of YHWH for his people to return to him. Fourth, Jesus lamented the persecutions and murders of the Old Covenant prophets as if he himself had sent the prophets and then arrived as their superior. This interpretation is shortly confirmed by Jesus’s Parable of the Wicked Tenants (20:9–18) and the resultant opposition against Jesus by Jerusalem’s leaders (20:19–20). And fifth, Jesus’s use of Ps 118 implied that he himself had forsaken Jerusalem’s “house” (whether that be the temple, city, or nation) and would remain unseen by them until they declared that he was coming in the name of the Lord/YHWH (Luke 13:35). These features support the interpretation that Jesus identified as YHWH by applying YHWH-texts, such as Deut 32:11 and Ps 91:4, to himself. (Scott Brazil, Jesus and YHWH-Texts in the Synoptic Gospels [Library of New Testament Studies 694; London: T&T Clark, 2024], 152-53)