Wednesday, July 23, 2025

Wolf-Dietrich Niemeier on the Evidence for Contact Between Greeks and Canaan During the Early Iron Age I (12th-11th centuries BC)

  

However, there are certain indicators that people from the Aegean were present in Early Iron Age I in Canaan. These include terracotta figurines of ritual function and Mycenaean tradition (Dothan 1995: 48, 50, fig. 3:12), hearths that were not common before in Canaan but in the Mycenaean palaces and shrines (Dothan 1992: 96; 1995: 42-45; 1998: 155- 58), kitchen ware of Mycenaean types (Dothan 1995: 46-47, fig. 3.7:10, 15-17; 1998: 154, fig. 5: 15-17; Killebrew 1998: 397, figs. 7, 10:13-14, 12: 14-15), the introduction of pork and beef into the diet (Hesse 1986: 17-27; Dothan 1998: 154; Kille- brew 1998: 397), and Mycenaean-type loomweights (Dothan 1995: 46-47). Vanschoonwinkel (1999), who argues that the Philistines were not of Aegean origin but Canaanite people, ignores important evidence such as the Mycenaean-type kitchen ware and loomweights and changes in the diet in the first phase of Philistine settlement. Ventris's decipherment of the Mycenaean Linear B script used for administrative purposes in the Late Bronze Age Aegean demonstrated that it had been used to write an early form of the Greek language (Ventris and Chadwick 1956; Chadwick 1958). Thus we may term the Philistines "Greeks,"7 although non-Greek- speaking groups, such as "Minoans" from Crete, may have been among them.8 After becoming firmly established in their Pentapolis, the Philistines began first to compete with the Israelite tribes and later with the kingdoms of Saul, David, and Solomon for political and cultural hegemony over the region. From the middle of the 12th century B.C. on, their pottery and other items of their material culture show signs of acculturation. Around the mid-tenth century, Philistia deteriorated into a minor political entity and rapidly lost its distinct cultural character, although the Philistines' sense of ethnic identity remained secure for several more centuries; in the Bible Philistia was defined through the Iron Age by geopolitical and cultural boundaries and was viewed by the Israelites as a separate region (Dothan 1982: 13-16, 160-91, 251; B. Mazar 1992: 34-41; Gitin 1998a). Although the royal dedicatory inscription from the seventh century B.C. Temple Complex 650 at Tel Miqne-Ekron is written in a language close to Phoenician, the name of the dedicating king, Ahish, is non-West Semitic and Perhaps Greek in origin (Gitin, Dothan, and Naveh 1997; Gitin 1998a: 173-74). (Wolf-Dietrich Niemeier, “Archaic Greeks in the Orient: Textual and Archaeological Evidence,” Bulletin of the American Schools of Oriental Research 322 [May 2001]: 12)