Wednesday, September 3, 2025

Lee Martin McDonald on the Reference to "Psalms" in Luke 24:44 in The Oxford Handbook of The Writings of the Hebrew Bible (2019)

  

The reference to “psalms” in Luke 24:44 may well be an early sign of an emerging third part of the Hebrew scriptures, but the early church fathers did not pick up on this and never equated “psalms” with the Writings in the HB or even the other poetic and wisdom texts. Although in Luke 24:44 Jesus explained to his disciples what was written about him in “the law of Moses, the prophets, and the psalms,” the last designation is unlikely to be anything more than the Psalms and it is best understood in conjunction with 24:27, where Jesus explains from the scriptures to the disciples on the road to Emmaus the same thing “beginning with Moses and all the prophets.” The “psalms” of 24:44 is obviously included in “all the prophets” in 24:27. Nevertheless, when “psalms” (or “David”) is listed in ancient collections of scriptures, it is only a reference to psalms and not all of the Writings. Interestingly, when Judas Maccabaeus encouraged his troops to go to battle by “encouraging them from the law and the prophets . . .” (2 Macc 15:9), Barr observes that he would hardly have ignored Ps 68:1 had the Writings been a distinct collection at that time (Barr 1983: 54– 55).

 

No evidence suggests that there was a widely understood tripartite canon of scriptures circulating in the first century CE. The most common designation for the Jewish scriptures then and even later was “law and the prophets” (see Lim 2013: 93– 137, 156– 165; and McDonald 2017: 160–295). While a widely recognized bipartite collection of Jewish Scriptures existed at the end of the first century CE, its scope was still fluid and not yet tripartite. (Lee Martin McDonald, “The Reception of the Writings of their Place in the Biblical Canon,” in The Oxford Handbook of The Writings of the Hebrew Bible, ed. Donn F. Morgan [Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2019], 407)