Saturday, October 17, 2020

John Calvin: Infants Elected to Salvation Based on the Spiritual Status of their Parents

In an appendix to one of his tracts, Calvin (1509-1564) argued that the children of believers were included among the elect:

 

I do not derogate from the efficacy of Baptism: I do not obscure the legitimate use of it; I only do not allow the salvation of the soul to be so tied to the sign as to make the Divine promise insufficient. The Children of believers, before they were begotten, were adopted by the Lord when he said, “I will be your God, and the God of your seed.” (Gen. xvii. 7.) That in this promise the Baptism of Infants is included is absolutely certain. (John Calvin, "Appendix to the Tract on The True Method of Reforming the Church: In which Calvin Refutes the Censure of an Anonymous Printer on the Sanctification of Infants and Baptism by Women,” in Tracts, Volume 3 [trans. Henry Beveridge; Edinburgh: Calvin Translation Society, 1851], 347)

 

Such is difficult to reconcile with Reformed theology, as it would appear that there is a spiritual benefit to the status of one’s parents vis-à-vis one’s election (from the eternal past)—it would appear to make one’s election contingent, not unconditional, in some important ways.

 

For more on the historic Reformed belief in “elect infants” and baptism being, in some sense, salvific for such infants, see:

 

Cornelius Burges (1589-1665) on Baptismal Regeneration of Elect Infants in Reformed Confessions

 

For a discussion of why Calvinism itself is a false gospel (cf. Gal 1:6-9), see:

 

An Examination and Critique of the Theological Presuppositions Underlying Reformed Theology