Sunday, August 29, 2021

Randal Rauser on the A Priori Assumptions as to Why Isaiah 44:7 is Privileged Over Genesis 22:12 by Critics of Open Theism

While a critic of Open Theism, one does appreciate the intellectual honesty Randal Rauser demonstrates in his assumptions and how they colour how he exegetes and privileges certain texts over others (in this case, Isa 44:7 being the “controlling verse” of Gen 22:12 as opposed to vice versa):

 

But on what do I base this assumption of divine omniscience? Like a biblicist, I could limit my case to biblical passages which suggest that God has intimate foreknowledge of creaturely actions (e.g. Psalm 139:16; Isaiah 44:7) and treat those as control verses for interpreting passages like Genesis 22:12 where God is described as learning. But that method is insufficient because it simply puts the question back a stap: what ultimately justifies privileging passages like Isaiah 44:7 as the interpretive control over passages like Genesis 22:12 (This point has been effectively pressed by Open Theists)? At this point, I would argue that we can justify a specific set of interpretive control texts by way of a prior theological intuition, an a priori commitment to the priority of a particular concept of perfection, a concept that includes perfect omniscience. It is because I believe God is perfect and perfection includes comprehensive knowledge that I would prioritize Isaiah 44:7 as a control text for Genesis 22:12. (Randal Rauser, Jesus Loves Canaanites: Biblical Genocide in the Light of Moral Intuition [Canada: 2 Cup Press, 2021], 129)