Tuesday, February 1, 2022

Arthur Wallace, "Evidence in Science and in Religion" (1966) on the Apocrypha

I am always curious what Latter-day Saints have written concerning D&C 91 and the “Apocrypha” (“Deutero-canon” in Catholic circles). The following is from Arthur Wallace’s 1966 book, Evidence in Science and in Religion (I do not agree with everything he writes here; I am just reproducing it for those who, like me, enjoy looking at older treatments of topics by other LDS):

 

Joseph Smith was told by revelation that there many true things in the Apocrypha four years after the Book of Mormon was published. Joseph Smith knew little about the Apocrypha while translating the Book of Mormon, but note the following resemblance among the Book of Mormon, the Apocrypha, and the Dead Sea Scrolls:

 

a. They teach claim to be telling a story that was given to man by revelation and was had among most ancient prophets from the beginning and this has been transmitted through the righteous down through all periods of time.

 

b. They each claim that the knowledge of the righteous prophets was not shared with the rest of the world. Those righteous were hid away from the rest of the world.

 

c. In each, the inspired prophets wrote their knowledge down in books. Their writings were addressed to future generations.

 

d. The subject they each deal with is the “Big Picture of God’s Plan” for the world from beginning to end—“eternity to eternity.”

 

e. They each claim divine revelation in their own time.

 

f. They each consider time as timeless. They speak of things to come to us as if they had already come, as if future events were present. Another form of this is an example from Nephi, “ . . . for I did liken all scriptures unto us, that it might be for our profit and learning.” (1 Nephi 19:23)

 

g. In each the center and pivot of the whole plan of history is the Messiah.

 

h. In each according to the “plan of life and salvation which was fixed and determined before the foundation of the world, the each was made as a place of testing, men being free while here to choose the way of light or the way of darkness.” This, the doctrine of free agency or of probation, the “way of life” vs. the “way of darkness,” is common in the plan as described in these three sources. The Book of Mormon goes overboard in one place and mentions “light” six times in one verse (Alma 19:6)

 

i. Each reference claims that throughout history men have chosen darkness rather than light, indicating the general weakness of the human race. Many general apostacies are described in each of these three reference sources (Book of Mormon, Apocrypha, and Dead Sea Scrolls). The purpose of the church is each is to work with the wicked; nevertheless, the plan remains hidden to those who are in darkness. The Bible also reported general apostacies. One followed Adam, one after Noah, one before Christ, plus others.

 

j. Each teaches that the righteous can expect persecution. Most certainly the same pattern of persecution that was described in the Book of Mormon followed Joseph Smith and the members of the Restored Church from 1830 to 1900 A.D.

 

These ten parallels most likely are not accidental. Also no one has yet proposed a theory that Joseph Smith concoted the Book of Mormon in his mind after a study of the Apocrypha. There is no such evidence. (Arthur Wallace, Evidence in Science and in Religion [Los Angeles: Arthur Wallace, 1966], 52-53, emphasis in original)

 

Further Reading

 

John A. Tvedtnes and Matthew Roper, “Joseph Smith's Use of the Apocrypha”: Shadow or Reality?

 

Jared Ludlow, Exploring the Apocrypha from a Latter-day Saint Perspective (CFI: 2018)