I just listened to the debate between Peter D. Williams and James R. White on the Marian Doctrines; the exact proposition of the debate was:
"Do the Catholic Church's Teachings on Mary Constitute Authentic Christian Doctrine?"
This is one of the few areas where White and I are in agreement (e.g., see my response to Tim Staples on the Immaculate Conception or the powerpoints of my fireside from January 2017 on Mariology from a Latter-day Saint perspective). I will note that White did a lousy job, as always, defending sola scriptura. See my lengthy paper, Not by Scripture Alone: A Latter-day Saint Critique of Sola Scriptura. However, one has to give Williams credit--he is one of only a few Catholic apologists who are willing to debate the Marian doctrines (Robert Sungenis being another), and he presented one of the best cases for Catholic Mariology I have heard in a debate setting.
One can find the mp3 of the debate here.
"Do the Catholic Church's Teachings on Mary Constitute Authentic Christian Doctrine?"
This is one of the few areas where White and I are in agreement (e.g., see my response to Tim Staples on the Immaculate Conception or the powerpoints of my fireside from January 2017 on Mariology from a Latter-day Saint perspective). I will note that White did a lousy job, as always, defending sola scriptura. See my lengthy paper, Not by Scripture Alone: A Latter-day Saint Critique of Sola Scriptura. However, one has to give Williams credit--he is one of only a few Catholic apologists who are willing to debate the Marian doctrines (Robert Sungenis being another), and he presented one of the best cases for Catholic Mariology I have heard in a debate setting.
One can find the mp3 of the debate here.
