Monday, January 6, 2025

Douglas Mangum, Miles Custis, and Wendy Widder (Protestants) struggling to defend Creation Ex Nihilo

  

Creation from Nothing

 

A fundamental doctrine of creation holds that God created the universe ex nihilo, or from nothing. This doctrine has significant theological implications, the most important of which is the distinction between creation and Creator. The doctrine asserts that God is separate from His creation, not part of it. Additionally, the doctrine implies that since creation has its origin in God’s creative action, matter cannot be eternal; therefore, all of creation is dependent upon God for its existence.

 

The account of creation in Gen 1 depicts God bringing order to the chaos of a primordial earth. While Genesis 1:1 and Hebrews 11:3 support the idea that in the very beginning, God created matter out of nothing, the concept of creatio ex nihilo is not explicitly stated in the Bible. Given this, the potential ambiguity of interpretation in Gen 1:1–2 is often used to suggest that God was working with pre-existing raw materials. However, the emphasis on God alone acting to create the cosmos makes a powerful assertion about the nature of creation and the uniqueness of God. The biblical writers were not concerned with the question of where matter ultimately came from. Their appeal to God as creator was designed to enhance His sovereignty, not explain the origin of the universe. The explicit doctrine of creation from nothing developed in early Christianity in opposition to philosophical ideas about the eternal nature of matter. (Douglas Mangum, Miles Custis, and Wendy Widder, Genesis 1-11 [Lexham Research Commentaries; Bellingham, Wash.: Lexham Press, 2012], Logos ed.)

 

 

Tohu wabohu, “Formless and Void.” Genesis 1:2 is sometimes read as undermining the idea of creation ex nihilo because it seems to describe the chaotic condition of unformed matter awaiting the intervention of God. The Hebrew phrase tohu wabohu, often translated as “formless and void,” contributes to this understanding because the verse describes an earth that exists but is “formless and void.” What does it mean that the earth was formless and void? Did God’s creative action consist of shaping pre-existent matter, or did He create the matter first? Other uses of these Hebrew words throughout the ot suggest that we are asking the wrong question.

 

The phrase tohu wabohu is used to symbolize the chaotic forces of the natural world. The prophets Isaiah and Jeremiah used these terms to emphasize God’s absolute power to both bring order from chaos and to unleash chaos in judgment on a rebellious world (Isa 34:11; Jer 4:23). The words tohu and bohu simply refer to an empty and lifeless wasteland. The passages that invoke this chaotic imagery focus on God and His uniqueness, not the pre-existent state of creation (e.g., Isa 45:18). God brought form, function, and order to His creation. His blessing is symbolized by order; His judgment by chaos. (Ibid.)

 

 

To Support this Blog:

 

Patreon

Paypal

Venmo

Amazon Wishlist

Email for Amazon Gift card: ScripturalMormonism@gmail.com

Email for Logos.com Gift Card: IrishLDS87@gmail.com

Blog Archive