Monday, July 7, 2025

Clinton E. Arnold on Similar Verbiage Used for Christ in Colossians 1:15-20 and the Greek Magical Papyri

  

It is in the magical texts, however, where one finds profuse praise of the power of various gods and goddesses, exclamations of their sovereignty over the heavenly realm, the earth, and the underworld, and numerous epithets extolling their supernatural attributes. This is not surprising because practitioners of magic were primarily concerned with supernatural power and how to solicit the assistance of divine beings. Many of these texts use some of the same terminology and conceptuality as the Colossian hymn. I am not making a case for a genetic relationship of the source of statements in the Colossian hymn as my predecessors in the history of religions school did, but rather suggesting that interpreters should consider the contextual relevance of the praise of Christ in the hymn against the backdrop of rival claims to sovereignty.

 

A first-century silver lamella found in northern Asia Minor (Amisos, Pontus) begins with a series of divine epithets to describe the god called upon for protection: “I am the Great One who sits in heaven [‘Εγω ειμι ο μεγας ο εν ουρανω καθημενος] upon the moving vault of the whole cosmos, Arsenophris . . . the one who rules over kings. . . . Let no more harm appear! Drive away, drive away the lawsuit from Rufinia! . . . And may no poison [φαρμακον] harm me. . . . [I am] king of kings.” The Greek magical papyri are replete with ascriptions of power and sovereignty to the particular deity being called upon to grant the request of the suppliant. One of these texts invokes Helios in the most exalted term as lord of heaven and earth: “Hail, O lord, Great Power, Great Might, King, Greatest of gods, Helios, the lord of heaven and earth. God of gods: mighty is your breath, mighty is your strength, O lord” (PGM IV.640-43). Another text invokes Helios as creator of τα παντα—even of angelic powers:

 

Listen, Helios, father of the world; I call upon you with your name . . . [28 magical names are listed] . . . You are the holy and powerful name of considered sacred by all angels; protect me, so-and-so, from every excess of power [εξουσιας] and from every violent act. Yes, do this, lord, god of gods . . . [18 magical names are listed] . . . creator of the world, creator of the universe [κοσμου κτιστα, τα παντα κτιστα], .lord, god of gods, MARMARIō IAō. I have spoken of your unsurpassable glory, you who created gods, archangels, and decans [ο κτισας θεους και αρχαγγελους και δεκανους]. The ten thousands of angels stood by [you] and exalted the heaven, and the lord witnessed to your Wisdom [σοφια], which is Aion . . . and said that you are strong as he is. (PGM IV.1180-209)

 

In another text, Eros is called upon in an invocation and is extolled as creator of “all things” (τα παντα) and is also ascribed the epithet, “first born”: “I call upon you, author of all creation, who spread our own wings over the whole world . . . who fitted all things [τα παντα] together by your power, firstborn (πρωτογονε), founder of the universe . . .” (PGM IV.1749-58). The Great Mother is invoked as “the beginning,” eternal, the source of all things, and as sovereign: “[come to me] . . . Mother of all things . . . Beginning [αρχη] and end are you, and you, alone rule all. For all things are from you, and in you do all things [παντα], Eternal one, come to their end” (PGM IV.2834-39). (Clinton E. Arnold, Colossians [2d ed.; Word Biblical Commentary 44A; Grand Rapids, Mich.: Zondervan Academic, 2025], 348-49)

 

 

In a pagan magical text, Eros is invoked as the “author of all creation” (τον αρχηγετην πασης γενεσεως), “the founder of the universe,” “firstborn” (πρωτογονε) and—in precisely the same language as the Colossian hymn—as the one by whom “all things hold together” (τα παντα συνεστηκεν) (PGM IV. 1750-771, esp. 1770-71). The intent of all these epithets is to extol the power of the deity who is being called upon to perform the request of the suppliant. Yet the text also warns that this deity can bring pain, is sometimes irrational, is a generator of frenzy, and whose light becomes darkness.

 

The term also appears in a syncretistic magical text that has a mix of Jewish and pagan traditions for ritual power. Called the Eighth Book of Moses, the text contains an invocation to a god who “Holds together the vault of heaven and the earth” (δια σε συνεστηκεν ο πολος και η γη; PGM XIII.76). The same epithet is cited later in the text (PGM XIII.586). (Clinton E. Arnold, Colossians [2d ed.; Word Biblical Commentary 44A; Grand Rapids, Mich.: Zondervan Academic, 2025], 367)

 

 

Blog Archive