Sunday, July 13, 2025

Douglas A. Nyholm and the Prophecy of Joseph Smith that one day the Kirtland banknotes would be "as good as gold"

  

Re-issued or Counter-signed Kirtland Notes

 

On January 6, 1849 Church officials decided to countersign and re-issue these notes at par, because this could be done quickly and inexpensively. The notes were backed 80 percent by the gold dust in the treasury, as were the valley notes. This action fulfilled the prophecy by Jospeh Smith, Jr., “ . . . that one day the Kirtland Safety Society notes would be as good as gold!

 

. . .

 

The ”Anti-Counter” Kirtland notes are the “Holy Grail” of Kirtland banknotes. Of the notes that have both the Anti-Banking modification and having been countersigned for use in Salt Lake City, only a handful of all denominations survive. They are rarely offered for sale, and most are tightly held in private collections. The total number of specimens encompassing all three denominations encompassing all three denominations ($1, $2, and $3) is 13-18, and most have been well circulated. Presently there are no known uncirculated examples, and even an “XF/AU” specimen may not exist.

 

The following table will show the scarcity and collectability of the Kirtland countersigned notes. As of this writing there are over 60 countersigned notes in the census. This is a popular method for collecting Kirtland notes however it is much more difficult and also very expensive. Most desirable countersigned notes will exceed $10,000, these notes are also probably the most desirable of the Kirtland notes due to the number of significant signatures on each note. In addition to the two original signatures on the note, four additional people signed the note for re-issuance in Salt Lake City:

 

·       Brigham Young

·       Heber C. Kimball

·        N. K. Whitney

·       Thomas Bullock (Initials TB only)

 

The fact that they circulated in Kirtland Ohio from a bank without a charter and made their way to Salt Lake City where they were re-signed and re-issued, is in itself, against all odds of survival. Additionally, the countersigned notes were backed by gold from California, fulfilling Joseph Smith’s prophecy that the “Kirtland banknotes would someday be as good as gold.”

 

$1.00

15-20

$2.00

10-15

$3.00

8-12

$5.00

40-45

$10.00

15-20

Table #12
Estimated number of surviving Kirtland counter-
signed banknotes. (Douglas A. Nyholm, Mormon Currency, 1837-1937: The Best Book on U.S. Currency for 2010 [2d ed.; 2015], Location 1292-1296, 1387-1411 of 9728, Kindle ed.)

 

Further Reading:

 

Mormonr/B. H. Roberts Foundation, Kirtland Safety Society (cf. Primary Sources)

 

Resources on Joseph Smith’s Prophecies (e.g., Brigham Young's Reminiscence of Joseph's Prophecy that "the Kirtland notes would one day be as good as gold")

Blog Archive