Friday, April 1, 2022

Zacharias Ursinus (1534-1583) vs. the naïve claim that “all good works are filthy garments”

  

I. What Are Good Works?

 

Good works are such as are performed according to the law of God, such as proceed from a true faith, and are directed to the glory of God. Three things, therefore, claim our attention in the exposition of this question: 1. The conditions necessary to constitute a work good in the sight of God. 2. The difference between the works of the regenerate and the unregenerate. 3. In what respect, or how far the moral works of the ungodly are sins.

 

First, that a work may be a good and pleasing in the sight of God these three conditions are necessary: 1. It must be commanded by God. No creature has the right, or power to institute the worship of God. But good works (we speak of moral good) and the worship of God are the same. . . . 2. That a work may be good it must proceed from a true faith, which rests upon the merits and intercession of Christ, and from which we may know that we, together with our works, are acceptable to God for the sake of the mediator. To do anything from a true faith is: 1. To believe that we are acceptable to God for the sake of the satisfaction of Christ. 2. That our obedience itself is pleasing to God, both because it is commanded by him, and because the imperfection which attaches itself to it is made acceptable to God for the sake of the same satisfaction of Christ on account of which God is well pleased with us. Without faith it is impossible for anyone to please God. . . . 3. That a work may be good, it must be referred principally to the honor and glory of God. Honor embraces love, reference, obedience and gratitude. Hence, to do anything to the honor of God, and that for the sake of showing our thankfulness for the benefits which we have received. There is a necessity that our works, in order that they may be good and acceptable to God, should be referred to the divine glory, and not to our own praise or advantage; otherwise they will not proceed from the love of God, but from a desire to advance our own selfish interests and will thus be mere hypocrisy. God must, therefore, be respected first whenever we do anything; nor must we care what men say, whether they praise or reprobate us, if we have the assurance that we please God in what we do, according to what the Apostle says, “Do all to the glory of God.” (1 Cor 10:31.). yet we may at the same time lawfully and profitably desire and seek true glory, according as it is written, “Let your light so shine before men that they may see your good works, and glorify your Father which is in heaven.” (Matt. 5:16.) (The Commentary of Zacharias Ursinus: On the Heidelberg Catechism—The Protestant Christian Doctrines, Dating to 1563 [trans. G. W. Williard; Pantianos Classics, 1888], 487, 488-89)

 

III. Are the Works of the Regenerate Perfectly Good

 

The works of the saints are not perfectly good or pure in this life: 1. Because even those who are regenerated do many things which are evil, which are sins in themselves, on account of which they are guilty in the sight of God, and deserve to be case into everlasting punishment. Thus, Peter denied Christ thrice; David committed adultery, slew Uriah, attempted to conceal his wickedness, numbered the children of Israel, &c. The law now declares, “Cursed be he that confirmeth not all the words of this law to do them.” (Deut. 27:26.) 2. Because they omit doing many good things which they ought to do according to the law. 3. Because the good works which they perform are not so perfectly good and pure as the law requires; for they are always married with defects, and polluted with sins. The perfect righteousness which the law requires is wanting, even in the best work of the saints. The reason for this is easily understood, inasmuch as faith, regeneration, and the love of God and our neighbor, from which good works proceed, continue imperfect in us in this life. As the cause is, therefore, imperfect, it is impossible that the effects which flow from this cause should be perfect. “I see another law in my members, warring against the law of my mind.” (Rom. 7:23.) This is the reason why the works of the godly cannot stand in the judgment of God. “Enter not into judgment with thy servant; for in thy sight shall no man living be justified.” “Cursed be he that confirmeth not all the words of this law to do them.” (Ps. 143:2. Deut. 27:26.) Inasmuch, therefore, as all our works are imperfect, it becomes us to acknowledge and lament our sinfulness and infirmity and press forward to much the more towards perfection.

 

From what has now been said, it is evident that the figment, or conceit of the Monks in reference to works of supererogation by which they understand such works are done over and above what God and the law require from them, is full of impiety; for it makes God a debtor to man. Yea, it is a blasphemous doctrine; for Christ himself has said, “When ye shall have done all those things which are commanded you , say, We are unprofitable servants; for we have done that which was our duty to do.” (Luke 17:10.) (Ibid., 491-92)

 

V. Why Good Works Are to Be Done, Or Why Are They Necessary?

 

. . . .1. Good works are to be done in respect to God. 1. That the glory of God our heavenly Father, may be manifested. . . . 2. That we may render unto God the obedience which he requires, or on account of the command of God. God requires the commencement of obedience on this life, and the perfection of it in the life to come. . . . 3. What we may thus render unto God the gratitude which we owe unto him. It is just and proper that we should love, worship and reverence him by whom we have been redeemed, and from whom we have received the greater benefits, and that we should declare our love and gratitude by our obedience and good works. . . .

 

II. Good works are to be done on our own account. 1. That we may thereby testify our faith, and be assured of its existence in us and by the fruits which we produce in our lives. . . . “. What we may be assured of the fact that we have obtained the forgiveness of sins through Christ, and that we are justified for his sake. Justification and regeneration are benefits which are connected and knit together in such a way a s never to be separated from each other. . . . 3. That we may be assured of our election and salvation. . . . . 4. That our faith may be exercised, nourished, strengthened and increased by good works. . . . 5. That we may adorn and commend our profession, life and calling by our good works. . . . 6. That we may escape temporal and eternal punishment. “Every tree that bringeth not forth good fruit is hewn down and cast into fire.” “If ye live after the flesh ye shall die.” “Thou with rebukes dost correct man for iniquity.” (Matt. 7:19. Rom. 8:13. Ps. 39:11.)

 

7. That we may obtain from God those temporal and spiritual rewards, which, according to the divine promise, accompany good works both in this and in a future life. “Godliness is profitable unto all things, having promise of the life that now is, and of that which is to come.” (1 Tim. 4:8.) . . .

 

The question, whether good works are necessary to salvation, belongs properly to this place. There have been some who have maintained simply and positively, that good works are necessary to salvation, whilst others, again, have held that they are pernicious and injurious to salvation. Both forms of speech are ambiguous and inappropriate, especially the latter; because it seems not only to condemn confidence, but also the desire of performing good works. It is, therefore, to be rejected. The former expression must be explained in this way; that good works are necessary to salvation, not as a cause to an effect, or as if they merited a reward, but as a part of salvation itself, or as an antecedent to a consequent, or a means without which we cannot obtain the end. In the same way, we may also say, that good works are necessary to righteousness or justification, or in them that are to be justified, viz: as a consequence of justification, with which regeneration is inseparably connected. But yet we would prefer not to use these forms of speech, 1. Because they are ambiguous. 2. Because they breed contentions, and give our enemies room for caviling. 3. Because these expressions are not used in the Scriptures with which our forms of speech should conform as nearly as possible. We may more safely and correctly say, That good works are necessary in them that are justified, and that are to be saved. To say that good works are necessary in them that are to be justified, is to speak ambiguously, because it may be so understood as if they were required before justification, and so become a cause of our justification. (Ibid., 493, 494, 495)

 

Blog Archive