Friday, November 13, 2026

The 2027 Scriptural Mormonism Research & Podcast Fund

I decided to set up a GoFundMe for the blog & podcast for 2027 (e.g., books and articles for research; hardware & software that may be required, etc). I have also been invited to travel to a few places to give firesides, including England, Switzerland, and Mexico (would like to, but travel costs can be prohibitive).


Anyway, if you like what I do, do consider donating. All funds will go into the blog/podcast/related expenses. Thanks, and Happy Friday!


The 2027 Scriptural Mormonism Research & Podcast Fund

For those who are wary of GFM (it is safe, but I 'get' it), this is my PayPal.

Dr. Stephen Smoot DESTROYS Sean McDowell with FACTS and LOGIC

 

Dr. Stephen Smoot DESTROYS Sean McDowell with FACTS and LOGIC





BTW: as unlikely as it is, I would happily debate/dialogue with Sean McDowell on soteriology, sola scriptura, ecclesiology, and other topics, such as the nature of 'grace.' This would be important, as I am one of, if not the, LDS apologist who knows the most about Reformed theology. My email is ScripturalMormonismATgmailDOTcom.

Theodoret of Cyrrhus (393-457) on Isaiah 10:15

  

10:15 Shall the axe glorify itself without him that hews with it? Or shall the saw lift itself up without him that uses it, as if one should lift a rod or staff?

 

“Does the axe strike the wood without human intervention? Does the saw divide it into two, three, or four? Can a rod or a staff strike without someone to perform the action? How then can you think that you have become the master of the nations that you have conquered apart from my will?” He rightly compared him even to inanimate objects, since he was suffering from extreme stupidity and irrationality.

 

But it shall not be so

 

He says, “I will not leave you in your current ignorance, but the punishment will make you acknowledge the Master of all.” (Theodoret of Cyrrhus, Commentary on Isaiah [trans. Gerald L. Bray; Ancient Christian Texts; Downers Grove, Ill.: IVP Academic, 2026], 44)

 

Theodoret of Cyrrhus (393-457) on Isaiah 45:7

  

45:7 I am he that prepared light and formed darkness,

 

Here he calls the happy events—the end of slavery, the deliverance, and the return—“light,” and the unhappy ones—the siege, the subservience, the slavery—“darkness.” He says: “I am the author of both series of events, of the ones as of the others. I am the one who used Nebuchadnezzar to inflict the punishment and who chose Cyrus as the means of deliverance. And just as I am the Creator of light and darkness, and made each of them for the benefit of mankind, so I inflicted slavery on Israel for its own good and I gave it the gift of deliverance because of my goodness.”

 

who make peace and create evil; I am the Lord God that does all these things.

 

He has clearly taught what he labeled darkness and light. It is peace that he called “light” and the events that seem evil “darkness.” He called them evil not because they are evil by nature but because people look at them that way. We are used to saying, “Today is an evil day for me,” not because the day has changed its nature but because in the course of that day things have occurred that upset us.

 

Next, to demonstrate the truth of what has just been said, he once more calls on creation to share the joy; (Theodoret of Cyrrhus, Commentary on Isaiah [trans. Gerald L. Bray; Ancient Christian Texts; Downers Grove, Ill.: IVP Academic, 2026], 163)

 

Theodoret of Cyrrhus (393-457) on Isaiah 8:16, 19-20; 40:8; 51:6

  

8:16 Then shall those who seal themselves that they may not learn the law be made manifest.

 

By this he indicated that those who came near to grace had placed seals on the law and that they did not want ot behave according to tis demands. The three interpreters translated this more clearly: “Close up the testimony, seal the law among my disciples.” For it was useless for my disciples. On the subject of these disciples, another prophet said, “And they shall all be God’s disciples.”

 

. . .

 

8:19 And if they should say to you: “Seek those who have in them a divining spirit, and them that speak out of the earth,” them that speak vain words, who speak out of their belly: shall not a nation diligently seek to their God? Why do they seek to the dead concerning the living?

 

By this he accuses the Jews of having a spirit of contrariness. Throughout their life they have been the slaves of error, that have sought to contact the dead, they have questioned the dead concerning the living, and they had paid attention to oracular diviners, but they have not believed in the real miracles performed by the apostles. Yet they received the law to help them attain salvation and without demanding gifts, it guided their steps toward the truth.

 

8:20 For he has given the law for a help, that they should not speak according to this word, concerning which there are no gifts to give for it.

 

Yet because you do not obey the law that guides your steps, nor the apostles who lead you to the truth, but you prize only error, I will strike you with a range of disasters. (Theodoret of Cyrrhus, Commentary on Isaiah [trans. Gerald L. Bray; Ancient Christian Texts; Downers Grove, Ill.: IVP Academic, 2026], 34-35)

 

Isa 40:8

 

but the word of our God abides forever.

 

From the beginning, he said, he foresaw this and foretold it, but even though he knew about their future disobedience, he will preached salvation to them, because he knew who among them would accept the message of salvation. (Theodoret of Cyrrhus, Commentary on Isaiah [trans. Gerald L. Bray; Ancient Christian Texts; Downers Grove, Ill.: IVP Academic, 2026], 140)

 

Isa 51:6:

 

but my righteousness shall not fail.

 

This is also what the Lord said in the holy Gospels: “Heaven and earth will pass away, but my words will not pass away.” (Theodoret of Cyrrhus, Commentary on Isaiah [trans. Gerald L. Bray; Ancient Christian Texts; Downers Grove, Ill.: IVP Academic, 2026], 188)

 


Brent Johnson, Letter to the First Presidency (September 19, 1892) Querying Adam-God

 The following is a transcription of:

 

Bent Johnson letter to the First Presidency (CHL Call no.: CR 1 171)

 

Huntington Emery Co. Utah
Sept. 19th 1892

To the presidency of the
Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-
day Saints.

 

Dear Brethren

 

Being a teacher in the Huntington
Ward I desire to teach
correct principles. I apply to
you for instruction upon the
following subject.

I and five years since Pres.
Knight, Pres. Lee, formerly of
Goshen and to the Manti
Council & thus taught that
Adam was the father of Jesus
Christ the father of our spirits
& the only Lord whom we
should worship. To this was added
that Adam came to this earth
bringing with him his wife
Eve & that he was not created of the dust of the earth (as we
are taught by the Doctrine
& Covenants & also Pearl of Great Price.)

 

The following meeting held
by the Y.M.M.I. Prest
Johnson went to meeting
returning with one the above
mentioned books & there read
the word of the Lord to Adam
& Moses concerning the creation
of Adam from the dust of the
earth. I also read Enochs
testimony concerning the teach-
ings of Adam to his posterity
that they should repent & be
baptized in the name of the
Father Son & Holy Ghost. And
also the commandment of the angel
to Adam that he should worship
the Father in the name of the
Son, thus letting him know that all Then does thou shalt do it in
the name of the Son.

 

And in the language of Adam
we are taught that Adam of old
must is His name & the name
of His only begotten is the Son
of Man.

 

Three Years anticipated
to this Bro. J. D. Chase.
formerly of Nephi taught the
same doctrine at Antherly [Anthony?] during
at public gatherings repeating the
latter. Having only as a proof
for his statements that one night
he could gather from the sayings
of Discourses.

 

Yesterday at our high priest
meeting the same doctrine was
again taught by the following
named Brethren—J. P. Johnson
Anderson Allen (his counsellor)
Hugh McKee & Bishop Tackett
They drawing their conclusion by
a paragraph read from the
Doctrine & Covenants, concerning
the Seventh Angel spoken of in
the 88 Sec. & Bro. Johnson
given Bro. Theo. Stottworthy
read from the same book the
words of Christ unto Joseph Smith
saying, at one time I have given
you temporal commandments, are
not even unto you father Adam
whom I created. Measuring
that Christ could not be the Lord of
Adam, when He Himself had
created Adam. At the close of the
class and meeting counciler Anderson
Allen said that Adam was after
having created our spirits delegated
upon the earth, & thus begot taber-
nacles for those spirits which he
had created. Thus, placing Adam as our God
& the only God with whom we
have to do.

 

Now dear Brethren these things
have become a source of trouble
to me. I desire to teach the
truth, and I do not know how
to reconcile these teachings with
the revelations contained in the
Doctrine & Covenants, Pearl of Great
Price, and the Bible.

 

If Adam is our Father and our
God, and the Father of the spirits
of all mankind, why did he pray
unto another? Why was he commanded
to worship the Father in the name
of the Son? And why did Enoch
see the Father and the Son while
Adam also stood in their presence?

 

These things appear to me to be
plainly taught in the revelations,
yet many good brethren teach
otherwise, and claim President
Young taught it, and therefore
it must be true.

 

Now I know that President
Young was a Prophet of God,
and I also know that the Lord
has revealed many glorious truths
through him; but I also know that
the Standard Works of the Church
contain the revelations which we
are commanded to teach.

 

Therefore I desire to know if I
have misunderstood these matters,
or if there is some explanation
that will harmonize the teachings
of President Young with the
Book of Doctrine & Covenants,
the Pearl of Great Price, and
the Bible.

 

Should there be any writings or
instructions upon this subject
which I have not seen, I shall
esteem it a great favor if you
will refer me to them.

 

Trusting that you will pardon
the liberty I have taken in
thus writing to you, and hoping
that you may find time to answer
these questions,

 

I remain

Your Brother in the Gospel,

 

Bent Johnson

 

Huntington
Emery Co. Utah

 

Sept. 19th 1892

 

Thursday, November 12, 2026

Berengaudus of Ferrières (840-892) on the Common Proof-texts for Prayers to Angels and Saints in the Book of Revelation

On Rev 4:9-10:

 

In this passage, by the four living creatures the four books of the Gospel are indicated; by the twenty-four elders, the Fathers of the New Testament can be understood. Therefore the four living creatures give glory and honor and blessing to the One seated on the throne, who lives for ever and ever, because the teaching of the Gospel is read and preached throughout the whole world, through which glory and honor and blessing are given to the Father and the Son of the Holy Spirit. At the voice of the four living creatures, then, the twenty-four elders fell down before the One seated on the throne and worshiped the One who lives for ever and ever, because the saints of God, established throughout the whole world, when they hear the teaching of the Gospel, humble themselves in the sight of God, so that they may live with Him for ever and ever. And they cast their crowns before the throne, saying. We said above that good works were signified by the crowns; therefore the saints cast their crowns before the throne when they attribute to God, and not to themselves, whatever good they do, according to the command of the Apostle: “Let the one who boasts, boast in the Lord” (2 Cor. 10:17). (Commentary on Revelation by Berengaudus of Ferrières [trans. John Litteral; 2026], 91)

 

 

Rev 5:8:

 

We must inquire how the book could have been opened before the unsealing of the seals. But this must be understood spiritually. For the prophets foretold the coming of Christ, his passion, and his resurrection, sometimes through certain figures, sometimes with plain words; and the patriarchs also prefigured all these things in their own deeds. But Christ, when he was born of the Virgin, when he suffered, and rose again, and ascended into heaven, opened the book of the Old Testament, because the things that were signified there he fulfilled in deed. Afterwards, what in the Old Testament was obscure, and likewise in the New, he opened to the teachers of the Church through the inspiration of the Holy Spirit. And this opening is the unsealing of the seals. But what follows, that the four living creatures and the twenty-four elders fell down before the Lamb, refers to those same teachers of the Church; for as often as they recall to memory the birth, passion, and resurrection of the Lord, and call to mind in whatever ways these things were prefigured by the holy fathers and foretold by the prophets; as often as they do not cease to investigate those things which in the Gospel are set forth obscurely, so often is the sealed book opened to them. They fall down before the Lamb, when, by meditation on the divine Scriptures, considering the immeasurable mercy of God, they humble themselves in the sight of their Creator, and the more they cast themselves down in humility, the more they burn with love for him, because the humility that is practiced in the sight of God nourishes the love of God. By the harps, moreover, which the living creatures and the elders are said to have had, the mortification of the flesh is signified, as the Apostle says: “Put to death your members which are upon the earth: fornication, uncleanness, covetousness, and the rest” (Col. 3:5). But the golden bowels are the hearts of the saints, filled with spiritual wisdom, which are said to have been full of perfumes. And what the perfumes are he himself explains when he adds: “Which are the prayers of the saints.” And so that these perfumes may ascend to God, the psalmist prays when he says; “Let my prayer be directed as incense in your sight.” (Ps. 141:2) (Ibid., 97-98)

 

 

Rev 5:14b:

 

In this place the twenty-four elders have the same meaning as the four living creatures; therefore the elders fall down and worship when the holy preachers, the more they see their hearers have advanced in good works, the more they humble themselves in the sight of God, as Scripture says: The greater you are, humble yourself in all things, and you will find favor before God (Sirach 3:20). Next follows the opening of the seals, which must be believed to refer only to the opening of the divine Scriptures. For even the things that are said to have been done under the openings of the seals refer to the opening of the Old and New Testaments. And just as the whole body of the elect consists of seven parts, so there are seven seals, which correspond to each part, to show those things that are obscurely set down in the divine Scriptures, or what the deeds of the holy fathers signify. The opening of the first seal, then, refers to the things that were done before the Flood; the second seal to the patriarchs; the third to those who were under the Law; the fourth to the prophets; and the three openings that remain refer to the New Testament. The fifth opening refers to the martyrs; the sixth to the casting down of the Jews and the calling of the Gentiles; the seventh refers to the coming of Christ. And why the coming of the Lord is placed in the seventh place we shall say in what follows. But we must ask why the opening of the Old Testament is prefigured through the vision of the four horsemen; for the horseman is, on the part of the horse, irrational, but on the part of the rider is recognized as rational. Likewise, certain legal laws, on the side of the letter, are irrational, but on the side of allegory are shown to be very rational. (Ibid., 102-3)

 

 

On Rev 8:3:

 

The angel signifies Christ; he came because through the mystery of the Incarnation he appeared in the world. By the golden altar the Church is indicated. He is said to have stood before the altar; for Christ lay prostrate among unbelievers, who considered him a mere man; but he stood among the faithful, who believed that he was truly God. Therefore he stood before the altar, because to the apostles and the other believers, from whom the Church was then constituted, he revealed that he was God. By the censer which he held in his hand are shown the hearts of the apostles and of the other faithful. It is said to have been golden, because the hearts of the disciples, purified by faith and golden by the wisdom they had learned from Christ, were like gold. The censer is said to have been held in his hand, because the hearts of the apostles were in the hand of God, as Solomon says: “The king’s heart is the hand of the Lord; he will bend it wherever he wishes” (Prov. 21:1). Was the heart of that Solomon in the hand of God when he was worshipping idols? Was the heart of Antiochus or Herod in the hand of God? Were the hearts of the kings who persecuted the saints of God in the hand of God? They were in the hand of the Devil, who bent them toward whatever crimes he wished; but the hearts of spiritual kings, that is, of the saints, are in the hand of God, and therefore he will bend them wherever he wishes.

 

Consequently: “And much incense was given to him.” The many incenses are the teachings of the Gospel; for incense is placed in the censer so that, once it has received the heat of the fire, it may spread the fragrance of its scent all around. In the same way Christ placed the teaching of the Gospel in the hearts of his disciples, who, inflamed with the fire of love, spread the fragrance of their faith among all nations. Therefore it also continues: “That he might offer from the prayers of all the saints upon the golden altar which is before God.” There are many kinds of prayers; for the faithful pray with words, begging God that all their sins may be forgiven them. They also pray by giving alms, as the Lord says in the Gospel: “Give alms, and behold, all things are clean for you” (Luke 11:42). And in another place it is written: “Just as water extinguishes fire, so almsgiving extinguishes sin” (Sirach 3:33). They also pray by forgiving their neighbors for what they have done against them, as the Lord says in the Gospel: “If you forgive people their sins, your heavenly Father will also forgive you your sins” (Matt. 6:15). Likewise, they also pray by keeping the commandments of love, as it is written that “love covers all offenses” (James 5:20). Therefore, that person prays to God in a wholesome way who keeps God’s commandments; for it is of no benefit to us to implore God’s mercy with words and to provoke it by our deeds. So God gave “upon the golden altar from the prayers of the saints” when he placed upon the hearts of believers the faith, teaching, and actions of the apostles and of the other preachers; so that they might have been from what they could be instructed and what they could imitate. (Ibid., 163-65)

 

 

On Rev 19:1-8:

 

But in truth, by the twenty-four elders, the fathers who lived under the Law are signified. To them are joined the four living creatures, through which the New Testament is prefigured; because in the Old Testament, if it is understood spiritually, the New is contained. They chanted “Alleluia,” because, observing the legal commandments, they strove by good works to please God. By the throne, however, the prophets are signified, in that they were the seat of God, and through them he arranged his judgments. A voice went out from the throne, because from the prophets holy preaching proceeded. They sang praise to God, because they strove to serve him with all their strength. The great trumpet signifies Christ: the voice of the trumpet is the preaching of the Gospel; and by the voice of many waters is signified the multitude of nations confessing Christ; by the voice of great thunder are understood the elect who are to be born at the end of the world, and rightly by thunder, because they will announce the terror of the day of judgment. Therefore three voices once chanted “Alleluia,” because they have preserved, and will preserve until the end, the faith of the Holy Trinity and the doctrine of the Gospel, which proceeded from the great trumpet, that is, from Christ. Two parts, that is, the first and the second, belong to the law which we have said is natural; the two which follow, that is, the third and the fourth, to the law which was given through Moses; but the three which remain, that is, the fifth and the sixth and the seventh, to the law of the Gospel, so that they show that those men ought to remain in the faith of the Holy Trinity until the end of the world. (Ibid., 305-6)

 

 

Blog Archive