Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Kevin M. Clarke on the Evidence that Maximus the Confessor Considered the Lateran Synod (649) as the Sixth Ecumenical Council

  

Though the Lateran Synod would not be received as ecumenical, Opusculum 11 refers to the “six” ecumenical councils, with “dogmas flashing forth” from Rome, and cites Christ’s promise to Peter, which clearly indicates Maximus’s estimation of the Lateran Synod as truly ecumenical. (Kevin M. Clarke, “Introduction,” in St. Maximus the Confessor: The Opuscula and the Dispute with Pyrrhus: The Theological and Polemical Works [trans. Kevin M. Clarke; The Fathers of the Church: A New Translation 151; Washington, D.C.: The Catholic University of America Press, 2026], 57)

 

 

Let them first show these things from the patristic selection, and thereby the assumption of their own doctrines will be confirmed by them. But if they are unable, they should leave these matters behind; let them be aligned with us, being judged piously only from the God-bearing Fathers of the Catholic Church and of the five holy ecumenical councils, confessing him, one and the same Lord and God Jesus Christ, to be perfect God by nature according to all of them and perfect man by nature according to all of them, apart from sin alone. (Maximus, Opusculum 9, in St. Maximus the Confessor: The Opuscula and the Dispute with Pyrrhus: The Theological and Polemical Works [trans. Kevin M. Clarke; The Fathers of the Church: A New Translation 151; Washington, D.C.: The Catholic University of America Press, 2026], 163)

 

Maximum numbers “five” ecumenical councils here, and in Opusc. 15 (PG 91, 180C), but in Opusc. 11 (PG 91, 137D), he numbers “six,” likely suggesting that he regarded the Lateran Synod as ecumenical. (Ibid., 163 n. 17)

 

 

For the very ends of the inhabited world, and those confessing the Lord everywhere in a sincere and orthodox way, as light is undifferentiated in the sun, so also in the most holy Church of Rome her confession and faith looks directly from the radiance of the Patristic and holy dogmas flashing forth from her, even as the six inspired and divinely sweet holy councils sincerely and most sacredly decreed the revealed things, having affirmed the symbol of the faith. (Maximus, Opusculum 11, in St. Maximus the Confessor: The Opuscula and the Dispute with Pyrrhus: The Theological and Polemical Works [trans. Kevin M. Clarke; The Fathers of the Church: A New Translation 151; Washington, D.C.: The Catholic University of America Press, 2026], 173)

 

Elsewhere in the Opuscula, Maximus states that there are “five” ecumenical councils (see Opusc. [PG 91, 128B] and Opusc. 15 [PG 91, 180C]). Perhaps “six” is a careless copyist’s interpretation. IF now, however, does “six” ecumenical councils not suggest that Maximus regards the Lateran Synod as truly ecumenical? If so, it would also necessitate that this opusculum be written after October 649. (Ibid., 173 n. 1)

 

Elizabeth A. Myers on “Babylon” in 1 Peter 5:13 Being a Reference to Rome

  

A new piece of evidence emerges from a hermeneutical implication of the intertextual borrowing relationship between the author of Hebrews and the letter 1 Peter. Specifically, the high probability of intertextual borrowing suggests that the discourse of Hebrews reflects the author’s interpretation of parallel passages in 1 Peter. This justifies use of the hermeneutical practice of mutual interpretation, that is, interpreting parallel passages in light of one another.

 

A particular case of mutual interpretation which is relevant for the author’s identity profile involves parallel #65, “greetings from others” (1 Peter 5:13 || Heb 13:24b), where both authors extend similar greetings to their respective audiences, as shown in the parallel texts below.

 

1 Pet 5:13

Heb 13:24b

‘Ασπαζεται υμας εν Βαβυλωνι συνεκλεκτη και Μαρκος ο υιος μου.

‘Ασπαζονται υμας οι απο της ‘Ιταλιας.

She who is in Babylon, chosen together [with you], greets you, and Mark, my son.

Those who are from Italy greet you.

 

Although neither of the two authors reveals the location from which he is writing, mutual interpretation of the parallel greetings illuminates their whereabouts. Since “Babylon” is frequently identified as Rome in Jewish and Christian tradition, the statement in 1 Pet 5:13 is commonly understood as a veiled reference to Rome. Given the high probability of intertextual borrowing and the likelihood that Hebrews reflects the author’s interpretation of the parallel passage in 1 Peter, the reference to Italy in Heb 13:24b would seem to support a Roman interpretation. Accordingly, greeters in both cases probably are from Italy.

 

Although the greetings from others mentioned in 1 Pet 5:13 and Heb 13:24b do not necessarily indicate the locations of the two authors, the intertextual relationship suggests that the implication for provenance is the same for both documents. In other words, if the greeting in 1 Pet 5:13 indicates Italian provenance, then so too does the greeting in Heb 13:24b, and vice versa. However, if the greeting in one document does not indicate the author’s location, then neither does the greeting in the other document. Since the singular feminine article η (“She”) in 1 Pet 5:13 probably refers to a local assembly or church community, it seems likely that, in the case of 1 Peter, the location of the greeter also indicates the author’s present location, namely, Rome. Therefore, in light of the probable intertextual relationship between 1 Peter and Hebrews, mutual interpretation indicates that the same implication applies to Hebrews. That is, the location of the greeters indicates Italian provenance for both 1 Peter and Hebrews. (Elizabeth A. Myers, Authorship of 1 Peter and Hebrews: New Evidence in Light of Probable Intertextual Borrowing [Cody, Wyo.: Pistos Ktistes Publishing, LLC., 2020], 162-63)

 

 

Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Maximus the Confessor Interpeting "God" (θεος) in Romans 9:5 as a Reference to Jesus

  

Nevertheless, the divinely fitting things and the human things are indeed about the one Son. And we affirm those sayings that are in between, as, for example, when the blessed Paul should write, ‘Jesus Christ is the same yesterday, and today, and forever’ [Heb 13.8]. And again, ‘for us there is one God, the Father, from whom are all things and from whom we exist, and one Lord, Jesus Christ, through whom are all things and through whom we exist’ 1 Cor 8.6]. And again, ‘to them belong the patriarchs, and of their race, according to the flesh, is the Christ, who is God over all, blessed forever, amen’ [Rom. 9.5]. (Maximus, Opusculum 9, in St. Maximus the Confessor: The Opuscula and the Dispute with Pyrrhus: The Theological and Polemical Works [trans. Kevin M. Clarke; The Fathers of the Church: A New Translation 151; Washington, D.C.: The Catholic University of America Press, 2026], 160)

 

"Are you Smarter than a Robert Boylan?"

My friend Noah Airmet made this; it is hilarious. Do try to beat LJ's highest score:


Are you Smarter than a Robert Boylan?



Monday, November 16, 2026

Faustus Socinus (1539-1604) on the Relationship Between Jesus and the Holy Spirit

  

That man Jesus of Nazareth, who (as I at least think) is the very only-begotten Son of God, and no other either besides him or before him, must in my judgement, according to the diverse times, be reckoned greater — not indeed than the Holy Spirit, whom I am utterly persuaded not to be a person, but than himself; and that in respect of the Holy Spirit itself.

 

For without doubt he was, in this same respect, greater after his glorification than before. Nay, while he lived here as a mortal, he was in respect of the same Holy Spirit becoming daily greater than himself, Luke 2:40 and 2:52. Wherefore there is no absurdity at all in this, that the same Jesus of Nazareth — that man, I say — at the beginning and for some time needed the Holy Spirit as a teacher, but afterwards himself gave the Holy Spirit and taught others through him. Which is, of all the things which Christ is read to have as far as the Holy Spirit is concerned, the greatest and most excellent.

 

For what Jesus himself says in John — that the Holy Spirit will receive of his own and announce it to the Apostles —, and what he had said a little before — that he will not speak of himself, but will say whatever he has heard —, these things do not signify that the Holy Spirit will really be taught by anyone (for this applies only to a true Persona (person)), but these things are said by a Prosopopoeia, as very many others are; and they signify that that divine force and efficacy which the Apostles were to receive, and by which they were to be led into all truth, would teach them about such things as pertained to Christ.

 

For since it was certain that after Christ’s glorification — then, namely, when the Holy Spirit was to be given — it would come to pass that all things which were God’s should also be Christ’s own, and that therefore they were already said to be Christ’s, because of the certainty of the thing shortly to come, Christ could rightly say that the Holy Spirit, who was to speak of things plainly divine and to teach the Apostles about them, would teach those things which pertained to himself. Therefore he himself subjoins: All things whatsoever the Father has are mine. Therefore I said, and so on.

 

So much, then, for those words, because he shall receive of mine and shall announce it to you, in which the reason is rendered why the Holy Spirit was to glorify Christ. But Christ could not be glorified by the Holy Spirit for this reason, that Christ had taught him what he should announce — for however true this had been, it could in no way have appeared — but because, as has been said, he announced those things which pertained to Christ and to his glory; which was to be open to all.

 

But as for what pertains to those words, for he shall not speak of himself, and so on, the Lord Jesus said them in order to show that that Comforter, the Spirit of truth, would be truly divine and would disclose those things which God wished to be disclosed and which were most certain. Nor indeed does Christ say that he will hear anything from him, but simply affirms that he will hear. And so “not from me, but from the Father” is rather to be supplied; just as the same Spirit is said to proceed not from Christ but from the Father, John 15:26, although it is not channelled into the church except through Christ, after he has been glorified.

 

For the rest, as to what you think, that the only-begotten Son of God could have been filled with divine light without the intervention of the Holy Spirit — that would indeed be true; but if the Holy Spirit (as I have already said that I hold) is nothing else than a certain power and efficacy of God³, I do not see how any created thing (for you yourself confess that the only-begotten Son of God is a created thing) could be filled with divine light without the intervention of the Holy Spirit, however immediately it had received that light from God. (Faustus Socinus, On the Existence of the Only-Begotten Son of God: A Disputation Between Erasmus Johannis and Faustus Socinus [trans. Marcin Poholski; 2026], 162-63)

 

Jerome on Ephesians 3:5-7: The Content of the “Mystery” (μυστήριον; cf. v. 4) was Revealed to Biblical Prophets Prior to Christ

Jerome long ago refuted brainlets like Craig Schmall (AKA “Mormon Myths”):

 

 

The mystery of Christ, which the Apostle has partly explained above, seems to require a fuller examination: how was it unknown in other generations? Did Abraham, Jacob, Moses, Isaiah, and the other prophets know it or not? Scripture records that they foretold the coming of Christ and the calling of the Gentiles. Abraham, indeed, saw his day and rejoiced (Jn. 8:56), and it was said to him, “All nations shall be blessed in your offspring” (Gen. 22:18). Jacob also speaks prophetically of the one who would arise from Judah: “He shall be the expectation of the nations” (Gen. 49:18).

 

Moses also considered the reproach of Christ greater riches than the treasures of Egypt. (Heb. 11:26) And Isaiah says, “Behold, a virgin shall conceive in the womb and bear a son” (Isa. 7:14). And elsewhere: “There shall be a rod from Jesse, and he who shall rise to rule the nations; in him the nations shall hope” (Isa. 11:10). And lest this become too long, let it be sufficient to quote a few words from the Psalms: “All the families of the nations shall worship before him” (Ps. 21:28). And again: “All nations shall serve him” (Ps. 71:11). And yet more plainly, concerning the people of Israel and the Lord, the Savior: “Visit this vine and perfect it, which your right hand has planted, and the son whom you have strengthened for yourself” (Ps. 79:14-15). The provision concerning his body is also indicated in what follows: “Let your hand be upon the man of your right hand, and upon the son of man whom you have strengthened for yourself” (Ps. 79:18).

 

We must therefore either accept Montanus’s view that the patriarchs and prophets spoke in ecstasy and did not know what they were saying, or, if that is wicked, for the spirit of the prophets is subject to the prophets, they certainly understood what they said. And if they understood, the question arises how Paul can now say that the mystery was revealed to Christ’s apostles, though it had not been made known in other generations. We must either answer that Paul carefully and expressly testified that the mystery was unknown to the children of men, but not to the children of God, to whom he says, “I have said, You are gods, and all of you are children of the Most High” (Ps. 81:6). That is, those who received the Spirit of adoption, among whom were the patriarchs and prophets, knew God’s mystery. Or, if this interpretation is not accepted and seems too strained and forced, the discussion must turn to the claim that Paul did not state definitively and universally that the Lord’s mystery had been altogether unknown in other generations, but rather that the ancient patriarchs and prophets did not know it in the way it has now been revealed to his holy apostles. For it is one thing to know in the spirit what is to come, and another to accomplished in fact. Therefore John is called greater than all the prophets (Luke 7:28), because he saw the one whom the others had prophesied and pointed him out with his finger, saying, “Behold the Lamb of God; behold him who takes away the sin of the world” (Jn. 1:29). In the same sense, these words may also be explained: “Many prophets and righteous people desired to see what you see, and did not see it, and to hear what you hear, and did not hear it” (Luke 10:24). They certainly desired to see and hear what they knew was to come. If they did not know what was to come, how could they desire what they did not know at all?

 

We read in the Books of Kings that the Lord promised Solomon in a dream and said: “Because you asked this thing of me, and did not ask for yourself many days, nor ask for riches, nor the lives of your enemies, but asked that you might understand and hear judgment, behold, I have done according to your word, and given you a wise and understanding heart, such as no one before you had, nor shall anyone like you arise after you” (1 Kings 3:11–12). How, then, as some suppose, was the mystery revealed to Christ’s apostles but unknown to Solomon, when Solomon was wiser than all the apostles, and God’s voice had promised as much to the patriarchs of old? Solomon himself also speaks confidently of this: “God taught me wisdom, and I learned the knowledge of holy things” (Prov. 30:3). David, too, boasts of his knowledge of the hidden mystery, saying, “You have made known to me the obscure and hidden things of your wisdom” (Ps. 51:6). And to the one who vaunted his wisdom, God speaks through the prophet: “Are you wiser than Daniel?” (Ezek. 28:3).

 

We must therefore either hold to the interpretation discussed above: that the patriarchs and prophets did not know the mystery of Christ as it has now been revealed to the apostles, because possessing something in one’s hands is different from foreseeing it in the spirit as something yet to come; or we must say that, just as faces are not alike, neither are hearts alike. As the Apostle teaches, there are different gifts: one has prophecy, another kinds of tongues, another gifts of healing, another helps and administrations; one is wise, another faithful, one excels in knowledge of secrets, while another is content with simple faith alone (1 Cor. 12:4, 11). For not all have spoken, following Solomon’s example, about the natures of beasts and birds, and likewise of plants, so as to discuss everything from the cedar of Lebanon to the hyssop that grows out of the wall (1 Kings 4:33). Conversely, perhaps Solomon did not see every kind of sacrifice and worship of God as Moses did; Nor did the Lord speak to him face to face, nor did he possess or understand such a wealth of tools as those whose design the Lord showed him on the mountain (Exod. 32:41; 25:40). And just as the patriarchs and prophets are believed to have had certain things that the apostles did not have, so, conversely, as the time required and for the preaching of the Gospel, the apostles had a fuller knowledge of the mystery of Christ. The holy men of old knew it too, but not as the apostles did, since the duty of preaching rested upon them.

 

What, then, is this mystery that, as it is now, was not revealed in other generations? Surely what follows: that the Gentiles are coheirs, members of the same body, and sharers in the promise in Christ Jesus through the Gospel, of which Paul became a minister according to the gift of God’s grace, given to him through the working of His power. I know that adding the conjunction “and” makes the sentence awkward in Latin. But since this is how it stands in Greek, and every word, syllable, accent, and punctuation mark in the divine Scriptures is rich in meaning, we prefer to risk the sentence’s construction rather than its interpretation. The Gentiles, then, are coheirs with Christ, or, as we think better, may be coheirs with Christ, so that God may be our inheritance and we may be coheirs with Christ. This is also written elsewhere: “Heirs of God, and coheirs with Christ” (Rom. 8:17). This does not mean that some possession is divided among us; rather, the Lord Himself is our inheritance and possession. For He says, “The Lord is your inheritance” (Deut. 18:2), and elsewhere, “The Lord is my portion and my inheritance” (Ps. 15:5).

 

“Members of the same body” means that, just as one body has many members, for example, eyes, hands, ears, feet, stomach, and knees, and though they belong to one body they have their own distinct functions, rejoicing and suffering for one another, so those who believe in Christ, though they have different gifts, are joined together in the one body of the Church. In the first two expressions, that is, “coheirs” and “members of the same body,” one might suspect some difference within the one body. But when he added, “and sharers in the promise in Christ Jesus,” every distinction was entirely removed. For where there is a common share, everything is shared.

 

He also rightly added, “through the Gospel, of which I became a minister according to the gift of grace given to me through the working of His power,” to show that this was God’s grace, not his own merit. For he knew that he had been a persecutor and had ravaged the Church of Christ (see Acts 8:1-3; 1 Cor. 15:9); this humility entirely excludes any charge of arrogance. Some think he should be criticized for claiming that the mystery had been revealed to him, though it had been unknown to the patriarchs and prophets. But a disciple of humility would never swell with arrogant words, saying that the Gospel of which he is a minister came not from his own merit but from God’s grace.

 

Those who want the prophets not to have understood what they said, and to have spoken as though in a trance, also cite, in support of their doctrine, the passage found in many copies of Romans, where we read: “Now to Him who is able to strengthen you according to my Gospel and the preaching of Jesus Christ, according to the revelation of the mystery kept secret for eternal ages but now revealed through the prophetic Scriptures, and the coming of our Lord Jesus Christ,” (Rom. 16:25–27) etc. A brief answer must be given: in former times the mystery of Christ was kept secret not from those who foretold that it would come, but from all the nations to whom it was later revealed. It must also be noted that the mystery of our faith cannot be revealed except through the prophetic Scriptures and the coming of Christ. Let those who do not understand the prophets and do not wish to understand them, claiming that they are content with the Gospel alone, know that they do not understand the mystery of Christ which was unknown to all the nations throughout the ages. (Commentary on Ephesians by Jerome (4th century) [trans. John Litteral; 2026], 61-66)

 

 

Bradford Littlejohn on "Protestantism's Idolatry Problem"

  

PROTESTANTISM’S IDOLATRY PROBLEM

 

Protestantism today has an idolatry problem. And by that I do not mean what countless Protestant preachers on both the left and the right can be heard thundering from pulpits every Sunday—that we have embraced the idol of Mammon, or of the State, or of personal freedom, or of gluten-free dieting, etc. This may all be true enough, and yet when we seek to make the pervasive biblical warnings against idolatry relevant to the modern world in this way, we manage to miss a central strand of the Bible’s teaching on the subject: that we can make an idol of Yahweh, the Holy One of Israel.

 

We are accustomed to wring our hands uncomfortably about the fierce divine judgments visited on the pagan Canaanites in the Old Testament, but we cannot even bring ourselves to think about God’s sometimes equally fierce judgments on His own people not simply for worshipping the gods of the nations, but for making an idol out of the one true God. In one of the more tragicomic moments in all of Scripture, the children of Israel can be seen falling into this wickedness almost as soon as they have left Egypt, at the very moment when Moses is receiving the Commandments from God in fire and smoke upon the mountain. There, with the powerful and terrible presence of Yahweh apparent to their very eyes, Aaron is able to persuade the Israelites to fashion a golden calf and worship it as the god “who brought you up out of the land of Egypt.” Lest there were any room for confusion about whom this calf was meant to represent, we are told, “And Aaron made a proclamation and said, ‘Tomorrow shall be a feast to Yahweh.”

 

Absurd as it may seem, this sad scene is repeated time and time again throughout Israel’s history, most crucially at the moment when the people of God divide into two, Israel and Judah. From that point onward, true worship of Yahweh is scarce in the Northern Kingdom, which is left to oscillate between, at worst, outright Baal-worship, and at best, golden calf worship, worshipping the God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob under a false image. Even when the Jews finally repudiate image-worship after the Exile, they fall back into their old habits of worshipping the true God in a false guise, when the true God takes on flesh and they refuse to recognize or honor Him.

 

And indeed, this is the key point. We are apt to miss the lesson of the Old Testament’s many warnings against idolatry by chuckling at the benighted folly of those who needed some physical image with which to worship God. Indeed, some American evangelicals can be quite loud in their denunciation of more liturgical churches that use images or physical gestures in their services. Now is not the place to debate the merit of such denunciations. But what should be clear to us from the witness of Scripture is that what fundamentally concerns God is our tendency to worship the creature rather than the Creator—and this includes worshipping the Creator as a creature. The human heart is a “perpetual factory of idols,” as John Calvin observed, and there are two main production lines in this factory. One starts with a creature that we are particularly enamored of because it promises to meet our deepest desires and needs, and to elevate it into an object of worship. Of the two basic modes of idolatry, this is certainly the one we are still apt to hear sermons about. The other, however, starts with the Creator, the God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob, and shudders before His holiness and incomprehensibility; needing a God that can be put on a greeting card or in a praise song, our idolatrous hearts shrink this God down to size, and make Him more like us.

 

Thus we find ourselves faced with phenomena like The Shack, in which the protagonist is consoled in his grief over his daughter’s death by a God who appears in the form of an African American woman (the Father), a Middle Eastern carpenter (the Son) and an Asian woman (the Spirit). More recently, renowned spiritual writer Fr. Richard Rohr has claimed to introduce his readers to the doctrine of the Trinity as “the Divine Flow”: “whatever is going on in God is a flow, a radical relatedness, perfect communion between Three—a circle dance of love.” It is a circle dance that is not complete even within itself, for, writes Rohr, “creation is thus ‘the fourth person of the Blessed Trinity’! Once more, the divine dance isn’t a closed circle—we’re all invited!”

 

It might be easy to dismiss such heterodox pop spirituality (although if we did so, we’d be dismissing the millions of evangelical readers who turned these books into runaway bestsellers), were it not that the basic ideas behind these blasphemies have long been appearing in somewhat tamer form among our academic theologians. A couple decades ago, the evangelical academy was roiled by disputes over “open theism,” which cast aside the traditional doctrines of God’s eternity and omniscience in favor of a God who lives, learns, and loves right alongside His creatures, hoping they will make good decisions and everything will turn out right in the end. Although evangelical theologians for the most part succeeded in closing ranks against open theism as just a bit too explicitly heterodox, they have been more than content to flirt with less overt denials of God’s eternity, as Steven Duby’s essay in this volume notes. At the same time, the classic attributes of divine simplicity, immutability, impassibility, and aseity have often been casually set aside if not openly rejected. In his bombshell recent book All That is in God, James Dolezal has identified these trends, comprising a new theology of “theistic mutualism,” as pervasive among leading Reformed and evangelical theologians and biblical commentators of the later 20th and early 21st centuries. “In an effort to portray God as more relatable,” Dolezal summarizes, “theistic mutualists insist that God is involved in a genuine give-and-take relationship with His creatures.”

 

At the same time, a radical revision of Trinitarian theology has been underway for several decades, with the fierce traditional insistence on divine unity replaced by a “social trinitarianism” in which a community of three persons—redefined as no longer the mysterious Greek hypostases, but in the modern English sense of individual subjects characterized by personality—either flow in and out of one another in a radical egalitarian dance (if you are socially and politically liberal) or exist in carefully-regulated structures of authority and submission (if you are socially and politically conservative). Such formulations are simply inconceivable from the standpoint of historical Christian orthodoxy, whether Orthodox, Catholic, or Protestant. Equally inconceivable is the fashionable modern talk of “the Father turning his back on the Son,” of the “Trinity being broken” at Christ’s crucifixion, language that originated in Jurgen Moltmann’s radical theological revisionism of the 1960s and 1970s and took only a couple of decades to become domesticated into conservative evangelical orthodoxy.

 

We could identify many causes for the current chaos—from widespread historical illiteracy, to the appearance of new philosophical challenges or at least intellectual fashions (often Kantian and Hegelian in origin), to methodological biblicism or Christocentricism. At the more popular level, though, I think that much of what drives our theological revisionism is what has always lain behind the human heart’s penchant for idolatry: a hunger for a God who is like me, a God who can relate to me, and meet me where I am, a God who is real enough to be there beside me in the midst of suffering. Whether it’s the anguished search by modern theologians for a God who could make sense out of Auschwitz or the infinitely superficial spirituality of the evangelical condolence card remembering that God will help us “mount up with wings as eagles,” the fundamental drive—emotivist and anthropocentric—is the same. (Bradford Littlejohn “Introduction,” in God of Our Fathers: Classical Theism for the Contemporary Church, ed. Bradford Littlejohn [Moscow, Idaho: The Davenant Institute, 2018], vi-ix)

 

 

Blog Archive