Saturday, November 23, 2024

Notes on Malachi 2:16

 Re.: “He hateth putting away” (KJV):

 

First, the spelling of šallaḥ (“sending away,” “divorce”) in Hebrew can represent only two possible grammatical forms: the infinitive construct or the second masculine singular imperative. Now, the previous Hebrew word, śānē’, “hate,” is a transitive verb—that is, takes an expressed object. Therefore, it is much more natural to take the following word, šallaḥ , as a verbal noun (i.e., an infinitive) and as the object word of šallaḥ (i.e., “he hates to divorce” or “he hates divorcing”) than to construe šallaḥ  as a second-person singular imperative (“send away”), which not only denies śānē’ the object it requires but also involves an awkward and confusing shift in person: “For be has hated, [you] send away!” (John S. Bergsma, The Bible and Marriage: The Two Shall Become One Flesh [A Catholic Biblical Theology of the Sacraments; Grand Rapids, Mich.: Baker Academic, 2024], 142)

 

Re.: “for one covereth violence with his garment” (KJV):

 

This clause reads literally in the Hebrew “and [he] covers over his garment [with] violence.” To smooth the English, the RSV2CE translates the Hebrew perfect form, “he covers,” as a participle,” covering.” It is possible to repoint the third masculine singular prefect form, kissāh, as the masculine singular participle, kōseh, to appease our English (or Latinate) grammatical sensibilities, but this emendation is unnecessary. The whole clause is functioning grammatically as a second object of “he [the LORD] hates” earlier in the verse. While we ould prefer a relative pronoun at the head of the clause (e.g., ‘āšer or še-) to make the grammatical relationship clearer (i.e., “and the one who [wa-‘āšer] covers”), nonetheless the “unmarked” or “bare” relative clause is by no means unusual in biblical Hebrew; see Robert D. Holmstedt, “The Relative Clause in Biblical Hebrew: A Linguistic Analysis” (PhD diss., University of Wisconsin-Madison, 2002), 107-14. (Ibid., 142-43 n. 46)

 

 

 

To Support this Blog:

 

Patreon

Paypal

Venmo

Amazon Wishlist

Email for Amazon Gift card: ScripturalMormonism@gmail.com

Blog Archive