Friday, March 25, 2022

The Catechisms of Peter Canisius and John Butler on the Veneration of Images

Catechism of Peter Canisius

 

Peter Canisius (1521-1597) was involved at the Council of Trent as a theologian. In his 1555 Catechism, we read the following:

 

9. is the received use of images of Christ and his saints contrary to the first commandment?

 

No surely: for we do not, as the heathens are wont, worship images, stocks and stones, and if they were certain gods (for that is specially prohibited in this commandment,) but after a Christian manner, and with a devote mind we honor Christ himself and his saints there where they are represented unto us by their images set before us.

 

So does the Church both of old and of this present time teach with one consent, commending unto us the devote and reverend images: the use of which we have received as commended unto us, by Apostolic tradition; and we retain as approved by a most holy general Council of Fathers. Yea God himself appointed to the ancient Synagogue their peculiar images.

 

For which cause was condemned the error of the Iconoclasts, or Image breakers, as they that made no difference between the likeness of the gods and the Images of Christ and his saints, nor had any consideration of the time of grace, or the New Law wherein God himself being made man, has put upon himself in his one image and likeness which he created in the beginning, and has represented himself unto us in the same. And it is not only an absurd error, but also a most wicked madness of those that cast out of sacred places the holy images, and amongst them the Cross of our Lord, and with sacrilegious hands, pull down in a manner all the holy things they can. (Catechism of St. Peter Canisius, or A Sum of Christian Doctrine [English translation 1622, Latin orig. 1555], 41-42)

 

Catechism of James Butler

 

James Butler (1742-1791) was the archbishop of Cashel, in my native Ireland. He composed his catechism in 1775.

 

Q. It is lawful to recommend ourselves to the saints, and to as their prayers?

 

A. Yes; as it is lawful and a very pious practice to ask the prayers of our fellow-creatures on earth, and to pray for them. Thessal. v. 25. James, v. 16.

 

Q. Why do Catholics kneel before the images of Christ and of the saints?

 

A. To honour Christ and his saints, whom their images represent. Exod. xxv. 18, 19, 22.

 

Q. It is proper to show any mark of respect to the crucifix and to the pictures of Christ and his saints?

 

A. Yes; because they related to Christ and his saints, being representations and memorials of them. Acts, xix, 12.

 

Q. Why do Catholics honour the relics of the saints?

 

A. Because their bodies have been the temples of the Holy Ghost: and at the last day will be honoured and glorified for ever in heaven. Matt. ix. 20, 21.

 

Q. May we then pray to the crucifix, or to the images, or relics of the saints?

 

A. By no means; for they have neither life, nor sense, nor power to hear or help us.

 

Q. Why then do we pray before the crucifix, and before the images of the saints?

 

A. Because they enliven our devotion, by exciting pious affections and desires, and reminding us of Christ and his saints; they also encourage us to imitate their virtues and good works. Exod. xxv. 18, 19, 22. St. John, iii. 14.

 

Q.Is it not forbidden by the first commandment to make images?

 

A. No; if we do not make them for gods, to adore and serve them, as the idolaters did.

(The Most Reverend Doctor James Butler’s Catechism [New York: D. & J. Sadler Co., 1882], 32-33)

 

Further Reading


Answering Fundamentalist Protestants and Roman Catholic/Eastern Orthodox on Images/Icons


Blog Archive