The orthodoxy of the Roman See might be
praiseworthy, but praise of Rome did not always translate into obedience to its
bishop. This was certainly true during the debate over the dating of Pascha
(i.e., the Quartodeciman Controversy)—that is, whether Pascha should be
celebrated on the fourteenth of Nissan (the Jewish Passover) or on the following
Sunday, which was the Roman custom. The first signs of trouble occurred during
a visit of Polycarp of Smyrna (c. 156) to Anicetus of Rome (c. 153-68), but
according to the sources, after arguing back and forth they simply “agreed to
disagree” and maintained communion despite their differences. However, forty
years later, Victor of Rome (c. 189-99) requested that synods be held to settle
the issue, and attempted to excommunicate Polycrates of Ephesus and the bishops
of Asia when they refused to adopt the Roman custom. While most synods did
follow the Roman dating, Polycrates, “unafraid of threats,” vehemently defended
his church’s ancient practice and refused to conform. In the end it appears
that Victor, rebuked by Irenaeus and others for overreacting, never carried
through with this threat and that communion was preserved. Rome emerged from
the date with its prestige unscathed—after all, “convoking a series of regional
councils to try and pressure the Asians into conformity is a tribute to Roman
prestige” (Eno, The Rise of the Papacy,
42)—but it is clear that respect did not equal obedience. (A. Edward Siecienski,
The Papacy and the Orthodox: Sources and
History of a Debate [Oxford Studies in Historical Theology; New York:
Oxford University Press, 2017], 148-49)
Blog Archive
-
▼
2020
(1160)
-
▼
January
(71)
- Edward Siecienski on The Church of Rome and the Qu...
- The Eastern Interpretation of the “Rock” as Peter’...
- Melvin J. Ballard vs. the Heartland Model of Book ...
- Melvin J. Ballard on the Knowledge of the Gospel b...
- John Thomas, "Creeds the Source of Intolerance" (1...
- Stephen S. Smalley on the meaning of ιλασμος in 1 ...
- Robert Sungenis on Favouring "He" instead of "She"...
- Peter T. O'Brien on Colossians 4:16 and the "Epist...
- Author of Book on Mary Does Not Know what the Imma...
- Latter-day Saint Duped into Rejecting "Mormonism" ...
- Robert Sungenis on Colossians 2:14
- Archbishop Nicetas of Nicomedia’s letter to Bishop...
- Wilford Woodruff on Plural Marriage Not being Nece...
- J.J. Andrew on Jesus being "Sinful" and "Unjustifi...
- J.J. Andrew on the Justification of Abraham
- A New Catholic Commentary on Holy Scripture on απα...
- 1 Corinthians 15:29 and Baptism for the Dead in A ...
- Neal A. Maxwell on D&C 1:30
- Kenneth Whitehead (Catholic) on Sermon 131 and Aug...
- Articles on Some (of the many) Problems with Refor...
- Isaac Levy on the Pre-Exilic Origin of Synagogues
- Robert Sungenis Refuting Protestant Attempts to Do...
- Journey of Faith Documentaries
- Dictionary of Deities and Demons in the Bible
- Is Satan dead?
- Origen vs. Formal Sufficiency of the Bible
- Royal Skousen on the Question of Use of the KJV in...
- Royal Skousen on Isaiah 51:19-20 in 2 Nephi 8:19-20
- Bo Reicke on the Authorship of Colossians
- Royal Skousen on the JST
- George E. Demacopoulos on an Example of the Subord...
- Paul's Addition of the Genitive του θεου when Addr...
- Brittney Lowe Hartley on the LDS Understanding of ...
- James S. Anderson and the Ontological Existence of...
- Richard M. Grant on Slavery and Early Christianity
- Richard M. Grant on Baptism in the theology of Pau...
- L.D. McCabe vs. Charles Hodge on Calvinism and Com...
- L.D. McCabe on God's Character and Contingent Fore...
- Mosiah 14:6 using Plural "Iniquities" vs. Isaiah 5...
- Was Isidore of Seville (560-636) a “Supralapsarian”?
- Robert Sungenis on 1 Corinthians 6:11
- Nathan McDonald on 1 Corinthians 8:6 and the Ontol...
- Traces of Salvation History in the First Six Lette...
- Reformed Apologist Misinterprets the Reformed Unde...
- Ken Wilson on Psalm 51:4-5 and Total Depravity
- Ken Wilson on Free Will in the Apostolic Fathers
- Paul Hoskisson on "strait and narrow" in the Old T...
- Ilaria L.E. Ramelli on Acts 3:20-21
- I. Howard Marshall on Peter's and James' Alteratio...
- Joseph Fielding Smith Jr. on Water Baptism, not Co...
- Joseph Fielding Smith Jr. vs. Soul Sleep
- Joseph Fielding Smith Jr. vs. the common abuse of ...
- The People Responding in "One Voice" During King B...
- "An Introduction to the Book of Abraham" Now Online
- "Magic" being used by Old and New Testament Figures
- Eliezer Gonzalez and texts that purportedly teach ...
- Divorce and Remarriage in the Church Fathers and P...
- Michael T. Griffith on Divine Justice in the Book ...
- Joseph F. Smith vs. "Canonical Inerrancy"
- James White Admits 2 Timothy 3 Cannot be Used to S...
- Brigham Young Using "Elohim" to Denote a Single Di...
- The YEC Misrepresentation of Uniformitarianism
- Young Earth Evolutionists?
- Abraham H. Cannon's Diary Entry for July 10, 1890 ...
- Old Testament Instances of "Name" Being Used for M...
- In Defense of Truth (2004)
- Did Ignatius of Antioch Teach Sola Fide?
- Matthew Paulson Shoots Himself in the Foot about "...
- Tears and Other Emotions in Penitential Practices ...
- Matthew Y. Emerson on 1 Peter 3:19
- Anti-Mormon Author Admits that Non-LDS Scholars Ag...
-
▼
January
(71)