Anti-Mormon Evangelical Protestant: "Mormonism" can be Considered "Christian" in the Broadest Sense of the Term
Many (typically Evangelical) critics of the LDS Church denies that “Mormonism”
can be “Christian” in any sense at all. This, sadly, was the tact taken by a
scholar such as Craig L. Blomberg in his essay in The New Mormon Challenge (see the section, “Is Mormonism Christian?”
in Kevin L. Barney, A
More Responsible Critique). Interestingly, one Evangelical Protestant anti-Mormon
author, in a recent book, agreed that “Mormonism” can correctly be understood
to be “Christian” in a broad sense, if not the “narrow” sense (i.e., one who
accepts the [Latin/Creedal formulations of the] Trinity and other “fundamentals”
of “mainstream” Christianity). Under the
heading, “Defining Mormonism and Christianity,” he writes:
[Groups claiming to
be “Christian” but are not Catholic, Orthodox, or Protestant] can be called “Christian”
in a broader sense than the way it is being used here [i.e., groups accepting “Traditional
Christianity”]. Both broader and narrower uses of these terms are legitimate;
what is important is that we be clear about our intended meaning . . . In the
broadest sense of the term Christianity, Mormonism is a type of Christianity.
That is, the LDS Church and its offshoots originated historically from within a
broadly Christian context as a religious movement that views Jesus Christ as
their central figure. ON the other hand, in the somewhat narrower sense used in
this book, Mormonism is not a type of Christianity because it does not accept
some of the important, distinctive Christian beliefs that the three major
streams of Christianity—Catholicism, Orthodoxy, and Protestantism—all share. (Robert M. Bowman Jr., Jesus’
Resurrection and Joseph’s Visions: Examining the Foundations of Christianity
and Mormonism [Tampa, Fla.: DeWard Publishing Company, 2020], 11, 13, comments in square brackets added for clarification)
Blog Archive
-
▼
2020
(1160)
-
▼
April
(136)
- For the Month of May ("Mary Month"): Read a book o...
- The Use of Wisdom 2 in Matthew 27:39-43
- Rhyne R. Putman on the Development of Doctrine wit...
- Elder Kyle S. McKay on Our Reliance on God in LDS ...
- Heinrich Heppe on Necessity, God's Decree, Sin and...
- Heinrich Heppe (1820-1879) on the Intercession of ...
- Reformed Theologian Henrich Heppe vs. the naive vi...
- Reformed Protestant Apologist on God "Relenting" i...
- Richard A. Diehl on the Lack of Skeletal Remains o...
- Joshua Berman on the Fallacies of Some Modern Prac...
- Joshua Berman on Unrealistic Battle Numbers in the...
- David L Petersen on "sun of righteousness" in Mala...
- David L. Petersen on Malachi 1:11 and Allowable Cu...
- Anti-Mormon Warns Against the Use of "Parallelomania"
- Another Example of Why Sola Scriptura is a "Dividi...
- Adam Clarke and "without a cause" in Matthew 5:22
- Josiah Trenham (Eastern Orthodox) on Some of the P...
- Josiah Trenham on the Eastern Orthodox Rejection o...
- Amos 9, "the booth of David" and a refutation of t...
- 4Q246 and the Eschatological Worship of Believers
- "James White and Daniel McClellan: The Challenge o...
- David P. Wright and אלהים Being God, not "Human Ju...
- George Smeaton (1814-1889) on the Wrath of God
- "Ex Materia or Ex Nihilo? Creation in Genesis 1:1-2"
- Geoge Smeaton (1814-1889) on the "Criminality of U...
- George Smeaton on King David Being Justified Befor...
- Book of Mormon Central, "Joseph Smith's First Vision"
- George Smeaton (1814-1889) on 1 Timothy 3:16 and δ...
- George Smeaton Admitting John 3 was Universally In...
- John B. Carpenter, Answering Eastern Orthodox Apol...
- David Bentley Hart on Acts 13:48
- The Phrase "And shalt not remember the reproach of...
- Robert Sungenis on Titus 3:5 and Baptismal Regener...
- Robert Sungenis on 1 Timothy 6:16
- Brant Gardner on 3 Nephi 16:6-11
- Brian Enyart on Failed Biblical Prophecies
- Donald Harman Akenson vs. the Post-Partum Virginit...
- Mark A. Smith vs. the false belief people who expl...
- Ed Snyder, The Sacred and Secular Vocabulary of Or...
- Brant Gardner on the Christology of 3 Nephi 9:15
- Denying Tota Scriptura to Defend Sola Scriptura
- Norman Russell on Deification (and Transformative ...
- Thomas G. Weinandy, "Defining ομοουσιον"
- William DeArteaga on Calvin's Radical Cessationism
- 1 Clement 35:3-4 vs. Reformed Theology
- Hans Küng on the Qur'an and Its (mis)understanding...
- Hans Küng on the Qur'an and the Fate of Jesus
- Examples of Second Nicea Affirming the Veneration ...
- Richard Price on the Late Origin of Icon/Image Ven...
- David B. Haight on Moses and Elijah appearing to J...
- The Book of John and Writings on Metal Plates
- Athenagoras' Ignorance of the Concept of the Eucha...
- Protestant Apologist Admits Forensic Justification...
- John Thomas: His Friends and His Faith
- Protestant Fideism (Again)
- Arland J. Hultgren on Hebrews 7:27
- James Henry Owino Kombo on the Influence of Islam ...
- The Major Features of Neoplatonism and Aristotelia...
- Philo calling the Word as "the second deity/god"
- Bart Ehrman on Setne and Si-Osire and Luke 16:19-31
- Bart Ehrman on Romans 6 and Paul's Teachings on th...
- Resurrection vs. First Vision?
- Some notes on 1 Nephi 22:15 and Malachi 4:1
- Old and New World Execution by Hanging and Zemnari...
- "When and How in the History of Theology Did the T...
- Protestant Apologists Sam Shamoun and Steve Hays: ...
- Functional Atheists Celebrate (?) Easter
- The Use of the Old Testament by New Testament Auth...
- Psalm 58:11 and the ontological existence of plura...
- "Evangelical Scholarship’s Struggle With OT Proofs...
- Why Sam Shamoun is Wrong about Mormonism
- On 1 Corinthians 15:1-3, 17
- Greg Stafford, "Justin Martyr’s 'before all creatu...
- Irenaeus of Lyons on Jesus' Ignorance of the Parou...
- Gregory Stafford on the phrase "God of gods"
- Justin Martyr's Distinguishing between "God" and J...
- Joseph Smith Performing a Miraculous Healing Accor...
- Brigham Young and Orson Pratt on Divine Accommodation
- Brigham Young on "Christification"
- Philemon 1:18 vs. Double Imputation
- The Treaty of London (1915) and D&C 87:3
- Michael Hubbard Mackay on the Significance of the ...
- Bernadette J. Brooten on Paul and Female Homoeroti...
- Nebuchadnezzar being the recipient of λατρευω in J...
- Jay Dyer (Eastern Orthodox) Refutes Absolute Divin...
- Wylie Breckenridge (non-LDS) on Achieving Omniscie...
- Answering Fundamentalist Protestants and Roman Cat...
- Daniel R. Anderson vs. the Reformed Abuse of Ephes...
- D.A. Carson on John 11:51
- Michael L. Brown on Job 19:26-27
- Jeffrey R. Holland, James White, and Calvinism
- Elena Butova on Amos 9:11 and the Tabernacle/Booth...
- Elena Butova on James' Use of Midrash and LXX Amos...
- Articles Interacting with Jesus’ Resurrection and ...
- Nathaniel Lardner taking the common eisegesis of H...
- On the Number of Pages in the Lost "Book of Lehi" ...
- TDNT and Louw-Nida on Romans 8:29 and σύμμορφος
- D. Charles Pyle, "Do Freemasons Really Worship Luc...
- Ether 5:4 and the Personality of the Holy Spirit
- On Mary Whitmer and other Female Witnesses to the ...
- Brant Gardner on "Gold and Silver" in the Book of ...
- Some Neglected/Ignored Resources on the First Vision
- The Restoration of the Fulness of the Gospel of Je...
- Could Moroni Have Travelled from Modern-day Mexico...
- Recent anti-Mormon attempt to Answer the Three and...
- On the Nephi/Moroni "Problem"
- Did Joseph Smith Initially Present his encounters ...
- Joseph Smith's Encounter with the angel Moroni and...
- Douglas Beaumont on Polygamy and How, Using Sola S...
- The Number of Moroni's Appearances to Joseph Smith
- Bill Hamblin's Review of Early Mormonism and the M...
- The Use of "Magic" ("Superstitious Nonsense") by B...
- Jan Assmann on the meaning of "myth"
- John 10:27-29 and Eternal Security
- Jan Assmann on Exodus 20:3 and the Ontological Exi...
- Jan Assmann on the Question of Whether the Sea of ...
- Moses' Intercession in Exodus 32 and "Temporal Pun...
- Helaman 3:13-16 and the Merneptah Stele
- When Inerrantists Attack Their Own
- "Infantile Faith" in Psalm 22:9-10?
- Edward Stevenson (1820-1897) vs. God being in an "...
- "Adieu" in English Translations of the Bible and J...
- Live Tweeting General Conference this Weekend!
- The Difficulty of Distinguishing Between "Religion...
- Joseph Receiving the Plates on 22 September 1827 a...
- Biblical Examples of People Not Seeing Angels in t...
- Did the writings of Emanuel Swedenborg Influence J...
- Has Acts 9:7 been mistranslated? is there validity...