Tuesday, August 5, 2025

Jens Schröter on 4Q397 not being evidence of a tripartite Old Testament

  

With respect to the development of the biblical canon, a reference to 4QMMT is instructive. This document (which is attested by fragments of six copies: 4Q394399) consists of a letter with halakhic instructions concerning different ritual regulations. Whether it belonged to the texts of the yaḥad, was sent to the yaḥad, or just gives an overview on several matters concerning rituals and purity, is disputed. The early date of the writing (probably second century BCE) seems to point to a stage before the formation of the yaḥad, which in turn makes the writing particularly interesting with regard to the authoritative Jewish writings. In 4Q397 1421 1011 we read the following passage:

 

To you we have [written] that you must understand the book of Moses [and] the book[s of the pr]ophets and Davi[d the annals of] each generation.

 

This is probably the oldest text mentioning collections of authoritative Jewish writings, even older than the Greek preface to Sirach. The sentence refers to the authority of the Torah and the prophets, whereas the reference to David remains somewhat unclear. It may either point to the psalms as the third group of writings, since according to Jewish tradition “David” was the composer of the psalms. However, David may also be included among the prophets, as is probably also the case in Luke 24:44 as well: “the law of Moses, the prophets, and the psalms.” The phrase “annals of each generation” probably refers to Chronicles as another group of biblical books. The passage is therefore hardly a testimony for a tripartite or even four-fold Jewish Bible. It rather testifies to the authority of Moses (or the Torah) and the prophets. The prophets are thereby probably perceived as interpreters of the Torah as the main authority. (Jens Schröter, “The Biblical Canons after Qumran and Nag Hammadi: Some Preliminary Observations,” in The Dead Sea Scrolls and the Nag Hammadi Codices: Selected Papers from the “Dead Sea Scrolls and the Nag Hammadi Codices” in Berlin, 20-22 July 2018, ed. Dylan M. Byrns and Matthew Goff [Nah Hammadi and Manichaean Studies 103; Leiden: Brill, 2022], 160-61, emphasis in bold added)

 

 

Blog Archive