Friday, March 11, 2022

Kevin Schembri on Canonical Age of Marriage in Eastern Orthodoxy

  

Canonical age

 

The Orthodox tradition sustains that the minimum age for marriage is fourteen years for men and twelve years for women. This condition is based on the age for marriage (aetas nubilis) that was suggested by Tertullian (c. 160-220) (De virginibus velandis, 11, 10), fixed by Emperor Justinian (527-565), and confirmed in the Syntagma (1335).

 

However, it is interesting that this principle was many times rendered flexible within the Christian tradition, as evident in the writings of Basil of Caesarea (330-379) (In the 4th century, Basil mentioned the age of sixteen and seventeen years for both marriage and religious profession. In canon 24, he also set the upper limit to sixty years for widows. Cf. Basil, Epistola 199, 18); in canon 20 of the Synod of Hippo (393) and canon 19 of the Synod of Carthage (419) (When discussing the age of marriage, the Synod of Hippo and the Synod of Carthage did not mention a particular age but made a simple reference to <<puberty>>); in the Ecologa (726) and other civil legislations of Emperors Leo VI (886-912) and Alexis I Comnenos (1081-1118) (The Ecologa of Emperor Leo III [cf. I, 4] and Novella 24 of Emperor Alexis I Comnenos set the age of marriage to fifteen years for orphan boys and thirteen years for orphan girls. On the other hand, Novella 74 of Leo VI declared the age of fifteen and thirteen for all boys and girls.); in the Kormc̆aja Kniga (In Chapter 51/50, the Kormc̆aja Kniga set the age of fifteen years for the male and twelve for the female), in the decisions of particular Orthodox Churches, and in the preparatory work for the Great and Holy Council of 2016 (The Inter-Orthodox Preparatory Commission of 1971 stated that it was advisable to keep to the local laws of the State. In 1982, the Pre-Council Conference agreed on these draft proposals). This flexibility was particularly present whenever the Church was faced with diplomatic difficulties and had to adapt her canonical age of marriage according to the personal wish of a particular sovereign or the civil code of their country. For instance, in 1299, King Milutin of Serbia (1282-1321) married Simonis, daughter of Emperor Andronikos II Palaiologos (1282-1328), when she was only five (cf. J. Meyendorff, <<Christian marriage>> 1039). However, in the countries where civil marriage was regulated by Islamic law, the Orthodox Churches were often allowed to regulate the age of their religious marriage. (Kevin Schembri, Oikonomia, Divorce and Remarriage in the Eastern Orthodox Tradition [Kanonika 23; Valore, Italy: Pontificio Instituto Orientale, 2017], 64-65)


In a footnote to the above, we read that 


In 1774, the Holy Synod of the Russian Church endorsed the age of the Ecloga, but in 1830, an imperial Russian law set the age of eighteen for boys and sixteen for girls. In 1849, the Holy Synod of the Greek Church forbade the marriage of a man under the age of eighteen and a woman under the age of fourteen. In 1877, the Holy Synod of Constantinople followed the Greek Church. It also abolished the norm that had been set by Basil of Caesarea and that impeded a man to marry a woman over sixty. (Ibid., 64 n. 343)

 

Blog Archive