Monday, September 30, 2024

James F. McGrath on John 5:1-18 (cf. Mark 2:1-12)


 

The version in the Gospel of John highlights what is merely implicit in Mark, namely, that the man was not required to immerse in flowing water in order to be forgiven. The Gospel of John does this by placing the man near a mikveh that he was unable to enter, with Jesus telling him to get up and carry his mat away home with no command that he immerse himself. The man’s reference to being unable to get into the water when it is agitated because of his immobility, so that others get in first and block his access, was puzzling to at least one scribe who introduced the detail about an angel descending to stir up the waters and give them healing power. Without that addition, the story may be read as one in which the man is seeking forgiveness for sin through baptism, and his only hope is the Pool of Bethesda beside which has been laid. The water would be considered living water only when the sluice gate was opened and the pool replenished with water that flowed from the valley. Jesus heals him, with the lack of requirement of immersion in flowing water made even more explicit than in Mark. Even if this is the significance of these gospel narratives, it is difficult to determine whether the trajectory leading from Mark to John is due to a departure from John’s practice by Jesus, or later Christian’s departure from the practice of John and Jesus. Moreover, if the Pools of Bethesda were an 339 (which is uncertain) that would readily explain both why the man sought healing there and why Jesus did not have the man be baptized there. In short, while there are possible hints of diverging Christian and Baptist practices, we cannot be sure the New Testament gospels provide evidence for it at such an early date that they involve disagreement between the historical John and Jesus. (James F. McGrath, John of History, Baptist of Faith: The Quest for the Historical Baptizer [Grand Rapids, Mich.: Eerdmans, 2024], 122-23)

 

 

To Support this Blog:

 

Patreon

Paypal

Amazon Wishlist

Email for Amazon Gift card: ScripturalMormonism@gmail.com

 

Blog Archive