Monday, August 17, 2026

Claude Barthe (RC Priest) on the Fate of the Unbaptized Infants and the New Funeral Ritual

 On the new funeral ritual, prepared in 1965 and published in 1969:

 

Was it appropriate to introduce a Mass “for a child not yet baptized”? Without giving any details about the “state” or “place” of children who die without being baptized, the Church clearly teaches the necessity of sacramental baptism or baptism of desire in order to obtain the beatific vision: “In the present order, there is no other means [other than baptism] of communicating this life to a child who has not yet reached the age of reason. And yet, the state of grace at the moment of death is absolutely necessary for salvation. Without it, it is not possible to attain supernatural bliss, the beatific vision of God.” (Pius XII, speech of October 29, 1951) The highly controversial contemporary document that contradicts this is merely a study proposed as an opinion by the International Theological Commission. The Mass proposed by the new missal, although clearly intended to console parents, nevertheless says: “May they [the parents] entrust him to your love”: “tuae sentient divinae pietati commissum [infantem ejus].” And in the farewell prayer (the absolution): “With confidence, we entrust him to God.” (Claude Barthe, The Seven Sacraments, Past & Present: A Short Critical Study of the New Rituals [trans. Karen Darantiè; Lincoln, Nebr.: Os Justi Press, 2026], 59-60)

 

Blog Archive