Wednesday, August 12, 2026

Addison Pratt on the Arrival of Protestant English Missionaries on the Island of Tubuai and their Claims Against LDS Theology (September 16, 1844)

While serving as a missionary on the Island of Tubuai in French Polynesia, Addison Pratt (1802-1872) recorded the following:

 

[London Missionary Society Missionaries Appear]

 

16th, Sabbath. This morning erly, it was rumored that another vessel was in sight. I hastily wrote a line to Brother Hills and told him if there was any news of importance to write a line and let me know what it is. I dispatcht a messenger with it, and soon after commenced my morning service. Near the close of it, there came in a rummer from Mataura, and after service was over I asked him, “What news?” He said the last vessel had landed 4 English missionaries, and I was wanted immediately. But he brought no letter, and I knew these to be a people easily excited. The weather rainy also. I consulted King Tommatooa who had come over to the see, and he said, “Wait till you get a letter,” and I attended to the farthermore services of the day. In the evening, returned my messenger bearing a letter from Br. Hills stating that those missionaries had been on shore telling the people all the scandalous reports that had ever been reported about the Mormons &c. Stateing that Joseph Smith is a liar and a false prophet and the Book of Mormon is a lie, that his followers worshipped him, and they also worshipped the Virgin Mary and the Saints and there was no differance between the prophet and the pope and much of such like stuff and the church members wished me to come there without fail on the morrow, for they would be there. (Addison Pratt, Journal, September 16, 1844, in The Journals of Addison Pratt, ed. S. George Ellsworth [Salt Lake City: University of Utah Press, 1990], 191-92, spellings in original retained)

 

One was reminded of other British Protestants, thosebrainlets from Reachout Trust (Mike Thomas and Tony Brown); as the French would say, "Plus ça change, plus c'est la même chose." Furthermore, reminded me of the following clip from one of my fave TV shows of all time:









Blog Archive