Let me make a few prefaces:
(1) "The Other Paul" (Paul Facey) is a super smart and capable Reformed Protestant apologist. He has produced some excellent material on the ecclesiology of 1 Clement.
(2) Akin did dodge a bit by defending a general concept of "magisterium" than the de fide Vatican I understanding thereof as well as understanding of oral apostolic tradition and other beliefs (absolutely no way he could positively defend Icon veneration, for e.g.)
With that being said: there is no question that Akin won this debate. I was expecting more from The Other Paul in light of his preparation for the debate (e.g., reading the [albeit, overrated] 3-volume Holy Scripture series by Webster and King). I do hope that this will result in him and Cameron (the host/moderator) rejecting Sola Scriptura.
For my work critiquing Sola Scriptura, see:
