Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Kevin M. Clarke on the Evidence that Maximus the Confessor Considered the Lateran Synod (649) as the Sixth Ecumenical Council

  

Though the Lateran Synod would not be received as ecumenical, Opusculum 11 refers to the “six” ecumenical councils, with “dogmas flashing forth” from Rome, and cites Christ’s promise to Peter, which clearly indicates Maximus’s estimation of the Lateran Synod as truly ecumenical. (Kevin M. Clarke, “Introduction,” in St. Maximus the Confessor: The Opuscula and the Dispute with Pyrrhus: The Theological and Polemical Works [trans. Kevin M. Clarke; The Fathers of the Church: A New Translation 151; Washington, D.C.: The Catholic University of America Press, 2026], 57)

 

 

Let them first show these things from the patristic selection, and thereby the assumption of their own doctrines will be confirmed by them. But if they are unable, they should leave these matters behind; let them be aligned with us, being judged piously only from the God-bearing Fathers of the Catholic Church and of the five holy ecumenical councils, confessing him, one and the same Lord and God Jesus Christ, to be perfect God by nature according to all of them and perfect man by nature according to all of them, apart from sin alone. (Maximus, Opusculum 9, in St. Maximus the Confessor: The Opuscula and the Dispute with Pyrrhus: The Theological and Polemical Works [trans. Kevin M. Clarke; The Fathers of the Church: A New Translation 151; Washington, D.C.: The Catholic University of America Press, 2026], 163)

 

Maximum numbers “five” ecumenical councils here, and in Opusc. 15 (PG 91, 180C), but in Opusc. 11 (PG 91, 137D), he numbers “six,” likely suggesting that he regarded the Lateran Synod as ecumenical. (Ibid., 163 n. 17)

 

 

For the very ends of the inhabited world, and those confessing the Lord everywhere in a sincere and orthodox way, as light is undifferentiated in the sun, so also in the most holy Church of Rome her confession and faith looks directly from the radiance of the Patristic and holy dogmas flashing forth from her, even as the six inspired and divinely sweet holy councils sincerely and most sacredly decreed the revealed things, having affirmed the symbol of the faith. (Maximus, Opusculum 11, in St. Maximus the Confessor: The Opuscula and the Dispute with Pyrrhus: The Theological and Polemical Works [trans. Kevin M. Clarke; The Fathers of the Church: A New Translation 151; Washington, D.C.: The Catholic University of America Press, 2026], 173)

 

Elsewhere in the Opuscula, Maximus states that there are “five” ecumenical councils (see Opusc. [PG 91, 128B] and Opusc. 15 [PG 91, 180C]). Perhaps “six” is a careless copyist’s interpretation. IF now, however, does “six” ecumenical councils not suggest that Maximus regards the Lateran Synod as truly ecumenical? If so, it would also necessitate that this opusculum be written after October 649. (Ibid., 173 n. 1)

 

Blog Archive