Thursday, August 7, 2025

Daniel McClellan, "Responding to Jimmy Akin"

While I disagree a *lot* with Dan, Jimmy is just really *really* deceptive in his representation of Dan and engages in really deceptive tactics, as well as tone & language policing (just another day ending in 'y' for Akin who can only debate if he can gish gallop).


Responding to Jimmy Akin




Such is not surprising, however. Akin's fellow co-religionists, Robert Sungenis, John Salza, and Christian Wagner, have shown Akin is more than happy to lie through his teeth.



Robert Sungenis and John Salza, "Akin White Debate Justification 2004 Part 1"







Robert Sungenis and John Salza, "Akin White Debate Justification 2004 Part 2"




Sungenis appeared on the Reformed Protestant podcast, "Iron Sharpens Iron" to discuss Akin's dissembling about "anathemas" in Catholic theology on Jun 21, 2024:




Most recently, Christian Wagner has caught Akin lying (and yes, I believe Akin is being deliberately deceptive--he wrote a book Teaching with Authority so knows all about theological notes, the formation of dogma, etc., so he cannot plead ignorant) on the theological status of Mary being free from personal sin in Catholic theology:






 

Response to Jimmy Akin. (Part 1)




St. Alphonsus Liguori AGAINST Jimmy Akin (a prime demonstration of Akin's penchant for quote mining)




For Akin, the answer is "yes" as long as it is done with sophistry and for the good of Mother Church!










Blog Archive