Monday, July 27, 2026

Keith C. Warner on Debates Concerning Latter-day Saint Baptism among Dutch Reformed in the Netherlands During the 1920s and 1930s

  

The Baptism Controversy

 

Baptism also became an issue in newspaper debates. An article in the Nieuw Rotterdamsche Courant on February 1, 1922, described baptism by immersion and concluded that “this way of baptizing undoubtedly had a virtue that was lacking in the easier way of putting a drop of water on the forehead of the candidate.” (De Ster, XXVII [March 15, 1922])

 

In 1932, the Dutch Reformed Church weekly, the Heraut, published an article debating whether or not Mormon baptism should be recognized by the church as Christian. The writer reached a negative conclusion. A later article in the Hervormd Weekblad der Calvinistishe Kerk considered whether a Mormon could be accepted into the Dutch Reformed Church without rebaptism, concluding that if the Mormon Church were considered Christian and that the baptism were performed in the name of the Trinity, then the baptism would be valid. The author concluded that Mormon baptisms appeared to be Christian, but he dared not say that it was a Christian church. (Quarterly Report, January 31, 1932, p. 3; Quarterly Report, November 16, 1935, p. 18)

 

After 1935, favorable articles concerning baptism for the dead, the welfare plan, missionary work, genealogy, and the Church’s building program appeared periodically in newspapers and various magazines. (Keith C. Warner, History of the Netherlands Mission: The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints [Dirk Kotter Publishing, 2026], 27-28)

 

 

Blog Archive