Thursday, September 3, 2026

Thomas Buckley on Salvation and Regeneration in Titus

  

Salvation through Jesus Christ and the Holy Spirit

 

“But when the goodness and kindness of God our Savior appeared, he saved us...” (Ti 2:4, 5). Thus does the apostle Paul recall to Titus the mystery of our religion (cf. 1 Tm 3:16). Thus does he introduce in the very heart of the epistle, a veritable compendium of New Testament theology, the epitome of God’s redemptive exercise (Ti 3:4-7). To a generation caught in the maelstrom of passion and even satanic hatred appeared God’s mercy incarnate in Christ Jesus and clothed in ‘‘goodness and loving kindness” (Ti 3:4). Though the Greek usage for ‘‘goodness” appears frequently in Paul, the particular word for ‘loving kindness” (philanthrōpeia) appears only here. It was actually much more familiar to the language of Hellenistic cults, especially to the cult of the ruler. And as in the preceding pericope which celebrated God’s grace (Ti 2:11-14), certain other terms possess a cultic resonance.

 

But again it is the tone which is significant. It enhances the solemnity which pervades this hymn to God’s manifest mercy. It enhances our sense of the Christian religion’s ageless mystery. Augustine recalled the text at least fifty times in the course of his writings. And through the generations the Roman liturgy has set forth its message of hope on Christmas day.

 

God has saved us, ‘‘not because of deeds done in righteousness, but in virtue of his own mercy” (Ti 3:5). The argument is Pauline. And that salvation which God works in his mercy waits upon “‘the washing of regeneration and renewal in the Holy Spirit, which he poured out upon us richly through Jesus Christ our Savior” (Ti 3:5, 6). Now the washing of regeneration and renewal in the Holy Spirit refers to Baptism. Verses 5 and 6 could very well derive from an ancient baptismal hymn. As a sacrament, Baptism is the very conduit of the Spirit and grace. And in its appropriation to the Holy Spirit, it is linked to the premier eschatological reality of the New Testament after Christ. For it is the Holy Spirit which effects regeneration and renewal in the light of the risen Christ.

 

Regeneration or palingenesia in Stoic tradition bespoke a cosmic restoration. In Jewish expectation it bespoke the renewal of the Messianic age. But here the usage bespeaks that spiritual rebirth which should issue in eternal life (Ti 3:7). The word may have been familiar to the mysteries, but the concept is different. Here regeneration waits upon the Holy Spirit whose largesse touches all, not merely the initiate. Though the typically Pauline concept of baptism which implies dying to the old man and rising with Christ (Rom 6:1ff.) is not brought to the fore here, regeneration bespeaks renewal in the Holy Spirit. And this latter concept is hardly introduced with the Pastorals. “If anyone is in Christ, he is a new creation,” Paul had written to the Corinthians (2 Cor 5:17). To be in Christ is to wait upon the Spirit. For it is the Spirit which would renew men and women after the likeness of Christ (cf. 2 Cor 3:18). And Christ, embodying that surpassing goodness and loving kindness which men predicate of a merciful God, abides our Savior, ‘‘so that we might be justified by his grace and become heirs in hope of eternal life” (Ti 3:5). Then, as though to conclude a solemn profession of faith or even a liturgical hymn, the pronouncement is made, “The saying is sure” (Ti 3:8). (Thomas Buckley, An Apostle to the Nations: The Life and Letters of St. Paul [Boston: Daughters of St. Paul, 1981], 481-83)

 

 

Blog Archive