Saturday, July 12, 2025

Enid S. DeBarthe (RLDS/COC) Claiming Joseph Smith Never Taught the Plurality of Gods Doctrine

  

Plural Gods. The idea that Adam was the god of this earth and that men can become gods of other earths has no basis in the teachings of Joseph Smith. Though the “Book of Abraham” (conceded to be a product of Joseph’s own mind) uses the phrases “strange Gods,” and “Gods of wood and stone,” in relation to heathen gods, it does not support the idea of plural gods. When speaking of the God of Abraham and his father, the phrase “the Lord their God” is used. Even through the word “Gods” is used in telling the creation story, the preceding phrase, “I am the Lord thy God, I am more intelligent than they all,” indicates Joseph Smith’s adherence to the Christian concept of God, and the word “Gods” is used for the Godhead.

 

A report in Times and Seasons of a sermon (known as the King Follett sermon), supposedly preached by Joseph Smith in April before his death in June 1844 and published after his death is the strongest support that can be offered for the idea that Joseph taught the plural gods doctrine. This report published under the editorship of John Taylor is not in the style or tone used by Joseph in his speech or writing. Besides the plural gods idea, it has the statement, “God is a man like unto yourselves,” and suggests blood atonement. The theme of exaltation, the questionable doctrinal ideas, the style, and the stone are all indications that this is a spurious report.re all indications that this is a spurious report. (Enid S. DeBarthe, “A Bibliography on Joseph Smith III the Mormon Prophet-Leader” [M.A. Thesis; Northern Illinois University, July 1969], 194-96)

 

Blog Archive