Thursday, July 17, 2025

Harry Whittaker on the Writings of John Thomas and Robert Roberts Often Being Preferred Over the Bible by Christadelphians

Harry Whittaker, who, up until his death in 1992, was a leading Christadelphian apologist, preacher, and author, cautioned against how many in the community privileged the writings of the “Pioneers” (i.e., John Thomas and Robert Roberts) over the Bible:

 

A mistaken emphasis

 

Here, incidentally, is where certain among us blunder badly (though with the best of intentions). They dogmatically urge you to "read the 'pioneers' and keep on reading them." Almost invariably behind this attitude is the tacit assumption that the worthies of an earlier time succeeded in discovering everything of real value that is to be discovered in Holy Scripture. A sorry proposition, truly, which those fine men–each one of them learners to the end of their days–would have had precious little esteem for. (Harry Whittaker, Reformation: A Book for Christadelphians [Warwick: Biblia, 2022], 31)

 

 

Further Reading:

 

Listing of Articles on Christadelphian Issues (e.g., Ruth McHaffie on Divine Inspiration being Imputed to John Thomas by Himself and Other Early Christadelphians)

Blog Archive