Monday, September 29, 2025

Charles B. Thompson (1860) and the Problem of Holding to Sola Scriptura and Condemning Slavery

The following is from Charles B. Thompson in 1860, a year before the beginning of the U.S. Civil War. I think it shows the problem of holding to sola scriptura, as one cannot, without being pretty inconsistent with such principle, disagree with the following:

 

Jesus, the great christian lawgiver, fearlessly rebuked all that was wrong in the practice of the ancients, such as polygamy, divorce for slight causes, hating enemies, rendering evil for evil, and the like; but he did not rebuke the practice of slavery or abolish the relation of master and servant, but on the contrary, we find his immediate disciples, the Apostles, sanctioning and encouraging the continuance of the relation, evidently proving it to have been a divine institution, sanctioned by the gospel of Christ, as well as by the law of Moses, and the practice of the patriarchs. This three-fold sanction, from the patriarchs from the law of Moses, and the gospel of Christ, has been the justifying defence of slaveholders against the maledictions of the fanatical abolitionists; but now by the discovery of the origin of the negro race as an original creation separate and apart from the creation of Adam, and they placed under the dominion of man by the Creator himself, we are forced to the conclusion that slavery as it exists in the Southern States of this Union, is not only morally and religiously right, but it is a duty enjoined upon the race of Adam by the Creator himself. (Charles Blancher Thompson, The Nachash Origin of the Black and Mixed Races [St. Louis, Miss.: George Knapp & Co., Printers and Binders, 1860], 76)

 

 

Blog Archive