Sunday, November 23, 2025

Strack and Billerbeck on Jewish/Rabbinic Parallels to 1 Corinthians 10:9

  

10:9 A: As some of them tested (him).

 

Mishnah ʾAbot 5.4: Our ancestors tested God ten times in the wilderness; as it says, “And they tested me ten times and did not listen to my voice” (Num 14:22). ‖ A baraita in b. ʿArak. 15A: R. Judah (ca. 150) said, “Our ancestors tested God (in the wilderness) with ten trials: two at the (Red) Sea, two with water, two with manna, two with the quails, one with the calf, and one in the wilderness of Paran. Two at the sea: once while going down and once while coming up. While going down, as it is written, ‘Were there no graves in Egypt (have you led us away to die in the wilderness)?’ (Exod 14:11). While coming up, as in the view of Rab Huna († 297); for Rab Huna said, ‘The Israelites of that time were among those of little faith קטני אמנה.’ This aligns with the opinion of Rabbah bar Mari (ca. 320); for Rabbah bar Mari said, ‘What does “They were recalcitrant at the sea, at the Sea of Reeds; yet he helped them for the sake of his name” (Ps 106:7, 8) mean? This teaches that the Israelites were recalcitrant in that hour and said, “As we come up from this side, the Egyptians will come up from the other side!” Then God said to the archangel of the sea, “Vomit up those ones (the Egyptians) onto dry land (so the Israelites may see that they are dead)!” He said before him, “Lord of the world, is there a servant who is given a gift by his master who then takes it away from him again?” God answered him, “I will give you (as a replacement) one and a half times as much as they number” (cf. Exod 14:7: 600 with Judg 4:3: 900). He said before him, “Lord of the world, is there a servant who demands something from his master (if he, e.g., forgets a promise)?” He answered him, “Let the stream of Kishon be surety (cf. Judg 4:7ff.; 5:21)!” Immediately he vomited them up onto dry land, as it is written, “And Israel saw the Egyptians dead on the shore of the sea” (Exod 14:30).’ Two with water, in Marah and in Rephidim. In Marah, as it is written, ‘And they came to Marah but could not drink the water of Marah’ (Exod 15:23). (After this,) it is written, ‘There the people grumbled against Moses’ (Exod 15:24). In Rephidim, as it is written, ‘They camped in Rephidim, and there was no water to drink’ (Exod 17:1). (After this,) it is written, ‘There the people quarreled with Moses’ (Exod 17:2). Two with manna, as it is written, ‘You shall not go out on the seventh day’ (so the midr. cites Exod 16:29), and they (nevertheless) went out (see Exod 16:27). Furthermore, ‘Do not let anything remain’ (so Exod 16:19 is cited), and they (nevertheless) let some remain (see Exod 16:20). Two with the first quails and with the second quails. With the first quails: ‘When we sat by the fleshpot’ (Exod 16:3); with the second quails, ‘And the rabble that was among them developed a craving’ (Num 11:4). With the calf, as it is (in the narrative of Scripture). In the wilderness of Paran (with the scouts), as it is.” (Hermann L. Strack and Paul Billerbeck, A Commentary on the New Testament from the Talmud and Midrash, ed. Jacob N. Cerone, 4 vols. [trans. Andrew Bowden and Joseph Longarino; Bellingham, Wash.: Lexham Press, 2021], 3:476)

 

Blog Archive