Monday, February 24, 2025

Baptismal Regeneration in "A Friendly Discussion"

In a booklet distributed by the Church in the early twentieth century, we read the following during a discussion concerning water baptism:

 

"And do you really believe that baptism brings remission of sin?" queried the lawyer.

 

"Certainly; provided, however, honest faith and sincere repentance go before it, and the ordinance is administered in the proper way by one endowed with divine authority; otherwise I believe it is of no avail whatever."

 

. . .

 

Let us examine the principle. Let us see if the idea of water baptism appears reasonable. The Lord has wisely and kindly selected this form of ordinance for the remission of sins. It was with this object in view that John advocated the principle. Peter promised it on the day of Pentecost. Saul also received aid to arise and have his sins washed away. And so it was taught by different disciples as a means whereby God would remit sins." (Ben E. Rich, A Friendly Discussion [Salt Lake City: Deseret News Press, n.d.], 17, 18)

 

This was (correctly) interpreted by critics as teaching baptismal regeneration. In a booklet written in response to A Friendly Discussion from 1928, we read the following:

 

NO SALVATION IN WATER BAPTISM

 

I would like to say a little more concerning water baptism. . . . in my opinion, it is far greater mockery for those who have understanding and know they are sinners and can repent, and believe to think that through water baptism their sinful heart is changed, and their sins are forgiven; that through water baptism they are regenerated, or born again. . . . There will be an awful awakening in eternity to those who believe that water baptism, in any form, or by any authority can regenerate the soul. It is a receiving lie from Satan, deluding multitudes into the belief that they are safe for heaven, when, as a fact, they are on the road to meet that wrath of God against the unrepentant sinner which is everywhere disclosed in God's Holy Word. (A Refutation to "A Friendly Discussion" (A Booklet Distributed by the Mormon Church") [Los Angeles: International Truth Distributors, 1928], 32, 33)

 

 

Further Reading:

 

Correcting Elder Kevin W. Pearson: Baptism Does Cleanse Us from Our Sins

 

To Support this Blog:

 

Patreon

Paypal

Venmo

Amazon Wishlist

Email for Amazon Gift card: ScripturalMormonism@gmail.com

Email for Logos.com Gift Card: IrishLDS87@gmail.com

Blog Archive