Tuesday, October 7, 2025

James D. Tabor on 1 Timothy 1:4 and the Warning Against "endless genealogies"

  

Since he is not focused: In one of the later New Testament letters attributed to Paul, the author laments Jewish groups that occupy themselves with “endless genealogies” rather than relying upon their “faith” to connect them to Abraham (1 Timothy 1:4; Galatians 3:29). Such a protest is not made in a vacuum. It is clearly directed against other followers of Jesus, most likely those who were connected to the Jewish origins of the emerging Christian faith—followers of James the brother of Jesus in particular, who did consider such matters of pedigree essential to the core idea of messianism. Paul refers to James in a dismissive way, although he is clearly the most authoritative figure in the early church—even above Peter and John. We must remember that Paul never met Jesus. He was a latecomer to the movement. Paul plainly says that he values his own visionary and clairvoyant revelations above the one-on-one experiences of those original followers directly with Jesus (Galatians 1:11-17). Paul refers to them as the “so-called Pillars of the Church,” but then adds, “what they are means nothing to me” (Galatians 2:9).

 

While Paul grudging grants that Jesus was descended from King David “according to the flesh,” he was not interested in the human Jesus, but rather in the heavenly Christ (Romans 1:3). He states unequivocally that he no longer regards Jesus “according to the flesh,” as having any importance (2 Corinthians 5:16). The phrase in Greek might be paraphrased as: “We no longer look at Jesus as a human being, born of a woman, but as the heavenly glorified Christ.”

 

In Paul’s view, pedigree and matters of ancestry became meaningless. Paul would no doubt have had the same attitude toward Mary: While she might be the mortal mother of Jesus, he writes that the heavenly Jerusalem now is the “mother of us all” (Galatians 5:26). Paul is interested in a new spiritual family that is determined not by what he calls “flesh and blood,” but by the new birth of the Spirit. (James D. Tabor, The Lost Mary: Rediscovering the Mother of Jesus: A New Historical Investigation of the Most Powerful Woman in the World [New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 2025], 187-88 n. 103)

 

Blog Archive