Saturday, February 7, 2026

Example of Debates Concerning Whether a Part of a Day is to Be Counted as a Full Day in the Babylonian Talmud

The following comes from Tractate Pesahim from the Babylonian Talmud:

 

            I.11 A. [4A] Rab was the son of R. Hiyya’s brother and the son of his sister. [Freedman: He was the son of his paternal brother and his mother was Hiyya’s sister on his mother’s side.] When he went up there [to the Land of Israel], he said to him, “Is Aibu [your father] alive?”

 

            B.         He said to him, “Mother is fine.”

 

            C.         He said to him, “Is your mother fine?”

 

            D.         He said to him, “Is Aibu alive?”

 

            E.         He said to his servant, “Take off my shoes and bring my clothing after me to the bathhouse.”

 

            F.          Three conclusions are to be drawn from the incident:

 

            G.        The conclusion is to be drawn: A mourner is forbidden to tie on a sandal.

 

            H.         The conclusion is to be drawn: A bad news that comes from afar is to yield a mourning period of only one day.

 

            I.          The conclusion is to be drawn: Part of a day of mourning is tantamount to the whole of that day. (Jacob Neusner, The Babylonian Talmud: A Translation and Commentary, 22 vols. [Peabody, Mass.: Hendrickson Publishers, 2011], 4:10)

 

Blog Archive