Saturday, January 11, 2025

Holly J. Carey on Psalm 22 and Wisdom of Solomon 2-5

  

Wisdom of Solomon 2 and 5

 

The argument that Wis. 2-5 is closely related to, and even dependent upon, Ps. 22 is not a novel one. This relationship manifests itself in at least three ways. First, there are several passages in Wis. 2-5 that are strong allusions to Ps. 22. Second, Wis. 2-5 shares several thematic parallels with the psalm, specifically in the situations of the respective protagonists. Third, by its use of Ps. 22, Wis. 2-5 portrays his protagonist as a Righteous Sufferer, going even further than the psalm (and interpreting it?) in explicitly identifying him as 'the righteous one' (ο δικαιος).

 

In Wis. 2.12 and Wis. 5.4 allusions to Ps. 22.7 are present in the adoption of the language of 'reproach', which shares the root of ονειδος (in the psalm) and appears in verb form in 2.12 (ονειδιζω) and in a different noun form in 5.4 (όνειδισμός). The nature of όνειδίζει as an allusion to Ps. 22.7 may be questioned by the intriguing role reversal portrayed in Wis. 2.12, where the Righteous Sufferer reproaches his foes, rather than being the object of reproach. However, Wis. 5.4 returns to a more traditional interpretation of the passage, where the Righteous Sufferer is reproached by his enemies, as is the psalmist. Another allusion to Ps. 22 is located in Wis. 2.18, where the persecutors of the Righteous Sufferer adhere to the same reasoning that the enemies of the psalmist display in Ps. 22.9:

 

 

Wisdom 2.18 εί γάρ έστιν ο δίκαιος υίος θεου άντιλήμψεται αύτοϋ καί ρύσεται αύτον έκ χειρός άνθεστηκότων
For if the righteous one is son of God, then he will help him and deliver

him from his adversaries.

 

Psalm 22.9  גֹל אֶל־יְהוָה יְפַלְּטֵהוּ יַצְילֵהוּ ִּי חָפץ בּּוֹ:
Commit to the Lord; let him deliver him. Let him rescue him for he

delights in him.

 

LXX Psalm 21.9 ήλπισεν έπι κύριον ρυσάσθω αύτόν σωσάτω αύτόν ότι θέλει αύτόν
He hoped upon the Lord; let him deliver him; let him save him since he delights in him.

 

Thus, the enemies of both figures have the same goal in mind when they persecute the Righteous Sufferer: they consider this punishment as a type of test for the two figures, and believe that the absence of deliverance from the Lord indicates that he does not claim the victim as his own.

 

There might also be an allusion to Ps. 22.21 here as well, with the reference to the potential for the deliverance of the Righteous Sufferer from the 'hand of those who oppose him'. Similar language is used in LXX Ps. 21.21, where the translators have interpreted 7 literally as 'hand' rather than 'power'. This verse constitutes a plea for deliverance from the psalmist's enemies, a request that is answered in the following portion of the psalm. The allusion to this verse in Wis. 2.18 indicates a correspondence between the 'dog/dogs' of Ps. 22.21 and 17, and the persecutors of the Righteous Sufferer.

 

There also exist several thematic parallels between Wis. 2-5 and Ps. 22. First, the protagonist in each text experiences persecution at the hands of his enemies, as Wis. 2.12-20 shares the general 'plot' of Ps. 22.7-9. Second, the suffering of both the psalmist and the Righteous Sufferer of Wis. 2-5 is considered to have eschatological ramifications which include his vindication, and this suffering is believed to be universal in its effect (Ps. 22.28-32; Wis. 3.8; 5.1-5). Third, both narrations of the opposition that the figures face are told from the perspective of the enemies in the first person (Ps. 22.9; Wis. 2.10-20).

 

Considering the previous discussion in this chapter of the existence of the motif of the Righteous Sufferer before and during the first century, the presence of 'the righteous one' as a title for the protagonist of Wis. 2-5 is significant. Even more important for this study is the fact that the persecution and anticipated vindication of this Righteous Sufferer is narrated in language that is largely taken from Ps. 22! This suggests that the writer of Wis. 2-5 regarded the psalmist as a 'righteous one' as well, and this lends strong support for interpreting the psalm as the lament and thanksgiving of a Righteous Sufferer figure. (Holly J. Carey, Jesus' Cry from the Cross: Intertextual Relationship Between Psalm 22 and the Narrative of Mark's Gospel [Library of New Testament Studies 398; London: T&T Clark, 2009], 116-17)

 

 

To Support this Blog:

 

Patreon

Paypal

Venmo

Amazon Wishlist

Email for Amazon Gift card: ScripturalMormonism@gmail.com

Email for Logos.com Gift Card: IrishLDS87@gmail.com

Blog Archive