Sunday, May 10, 2026

Robert Roberts (1839-1898) and Charles Curwen Walker (1856-1940): Adam and Eve Had No Children Before the Fall

While browsing through some works on Logos, I found the following two quotes from influential Christadelphians. Such is not a belief that is unique to Latter-day Saints:

 

 

35.—Why is man in his present mortal and evil state?

 

Answer:           Man is mortal because of sin. It is God’s law that sinners must die. Adam, our first father, sinned, and was sentenced to death before he had any children. Death began with him, and came to us through him. We receive the nature that he had after he was condemned to die. We thus inherit his sentence of death. Besides this, we are all sinners ourselves. (Robert Roberts, The Christadelphian Instructor [Logos Publications, 1969], 14)

 

 

We are sin’s flesh multiplied. Adam and Eve had no children before the fall, and the first baby, Cain, was “of the wicked one” (1 Jno. 3:12), and slew his brother Abel. Sin’s flesh is unclean and condemned to death. But that, of course, does not mean that God is angry with all the individuals of the race from babyhood upwards, including even his beloved Son, of whom a certain church hymn says that “He met his Father’s anger”! The truth knows no such enormity as this. This belongs to the mythology of the old “Mother of Harlots,” from which and from whom we have escaped. (Charles Curwen Walker, “The Putting Away of Sin,” in The Christadelphian 43, no. 510 [December 1, 1906]: 555)

 

 

Blog Archive