Wednesday, September 10, 2025

Peter Abelard (1079-1142) Addressing Whether Cain Was Damned in Sic Et Non

  

147      CAIN IS NOT DAMNED . . . OR HE IS

 

1.     Jerome to Damasus: (Hier., Epist. (ad Damasum) 36.5; PL 22.455) Therefore, just as the sin of Cain was absolved in the seventh generation, the Lord will not judge him twice, and one who receives evils once in his life, will not suffer the same tortures in death, which he suffered in life, etc.

2.     Gregory Moralia, book six: (Greg., Moralia vi.6, 7; PL 75:732 D) (Jb 5.3): “I saw the foot with firm foot and immediately cursed his beauty”. It is written that Cain first built a city, so it might be shown plainly that he, who was alien from the solidity of the heavenly country, placed a foundation on earth. (Yes and No: The Complete English Translation of Peter Abelard’s Sic Et Non [trans. Priscilla Throop; 2d ed.; Charlotte, Vt.: MedievalMS, 2008], 396)

 

Further Reading:

 

Mormonr (B. H. Roberts Foundation, “Cain and Bigfoot” (cf. Primary Sources)

Blog Archive