Thursday, March 27, 2025

Albert the Great (d. 1280) on the "For Many" vs. "For All" issue

  

Now to the question, why it does not say “for all,” some respond that the blood of Christ is truly sufficient for all, but since it does not effectively save all but many, “for many” is said rather than “for all.” And this is a good and Catholic reason. If anyone more carefully examines the word of the Lord, then more is meant by “for many” than if he had said “for all,” since “many” indicates a multitude that increases incrementally to infinity, and so it is better that “for many” is said, since, although it is a multitude of men, the potency of the matter, as the Philosopher says, reaches to infinity, and the infinite multitude is redeemed by the power of the blood. But if “for all” were said, the highest would be mentioned as understood under one common [notion] and the power of the blood would not be signified to extend itself beyond it. To the saying [1 Jn 2.2] that he shed his blood “for” the sins of “the whole world,” it must be said that in “world” there is expressed a certain infinity according to the potency of the matter, since the world is the same, past, present, and future, and so again it refers to a multitude infinite in potency.

 

Now through this, the answer is clear to the next [objection] about the words of John the Baptist, who said, “Who takes away the sin of the world.”

 

To the final question, about the addition “for the remission of sins,” it must be said that, in this [phrase], nothing is added but what befits the form of the blood, since the remission of sins is signified and caused in the blood alone according to the name and effect of blood. Indeed, it is caused in other things but not per se signified through them. For the body in itself does not bespeak the work of redemption, since the truth of the body could have been received even if there had not been redemption through the passion, provided that Christ had instituted the sacrament of his body. But the blood directly bespeaks the flow of blood in the work of redemption, through which the remission of sins and forgiveness of the debt were accomplished. (Albert the Great, On the Body of the Lord Distinction 6, Chapter 3 [trans. Albert Marie Surmanski; The Fathers of the Church Medieval Continuation 17; Washington, D.C.: The Catholic University of America Press, 2017], 387-88)

 

 

To Support this Blog:

 

Patreon

Paypal

Venmo

Amazon Wishlist

Email for Amazon Gift card: ScripturalMormonism@gmail.com

Email for Logos.com Gift Card: IrishLDS87@gmail.com

Blog Archive