Thursday, March 27, 2025

David Allen on Matthew 27:43 and Psalm 22

  

More significant perhaps is Matthew’s enhancement of other points of connection with Psalm 22, and in particular the further allusion to Psalm 22.8 and the chief priests’ mocking invitation to Jesus to let God deliver him (Matt. 27.43). Both Matthew and Mark have the derisive cry for Jesus to save himself and come down from the cross (Matt. 27.40; Mark 15.30), through with Matthean addition of ‘if you are the Son of God’ (perhaps an echo of the temptation narrative—4.3, 6). Technically, the mockers of Psalm 22 exhort God to deliver the sufferer (rather than it being a case of self-deliverance), and hence it is the common imagery of Psalm 22.8 and Mark’s wider use of the psalm (rather than the explicit language) that justifies the allusion, for Mark 15.30 at least. Matthew, however, offers a further or expanded allusion to Psalm 22.8. Where Mark has the chief priests and scribes effectively echoing the derision of the passers-by to self-salvation (15.31), Matthew incorporates the psalm’s exhortation to divine intervention and urges God to deliver the crucified, suffering Jesus (27.43). Where the psalmist portrays the mockers urging the sufferer to commit his cause to YHWH in the expectation of deliverance, Matthew’s mockers likewise parody the crucified Jesus that he should similarly put his trust in God in the expectation of divine deliverance. Matthew’s allusion to Psalm 22.8 is thus ‘louder’ than the Markan example and, indeed, becomes more like a quotation in this regard, with a closer lexical and thematic similarity between the text and its source. Like 27.40, it also species Jesus as ‘God’s Son’, to add further irony to the challenge for divine deliverance. Commenting on this ‘expansion’ of the Markan source, Marcus surmises that ‘in the transition from Mark to Matthew . . . we can see the narrative growing right before our eyes.’ There are even other potential allusions to the psalm, beyond that used by Mark. For example, albeit within the resurrection narrative, it is possible that Jesus’ exhortation to go to Galilee so that his brothers might see him (Matt. 27.10) echoes Psalm 22.22-23, particularly as Hebrews 2.12 also picks up such a reference. (David Allen, According to the Scriptures: The Death of Christ in the Old Testament and the New [Eugene, Oreg.: Cascade Books, 2025], 37-38)

 

 

To Support this Blog:

 

Patreon

Paypal

Venmo

Amazon Wishlist

Email for Amazon Gift card: ScripturalMormonism@gmail.com

Email for Logos.com Gift Card: IrishLDS87@gmail.com

Blog Archive