Thursday, January 1, 2026

Pope Leo the Graet: Jesus Assumed Mary's Human Nature but Not Her "Guilt" (Latin: culpa)

The following is from Pope Leo the Great, Sermon 22 (alt. 21), “In Nativitate Domini II,” found in PL 54:196-97

 

Cap. III.

 

Hoc ipsum autem, dilectissimi, quod Christus nasci elegit ex Virgine, nonne apparet altissimae fuisse rationis? ut scilicet natam humano generi salutem diabolus ignoraret, et spiritali latente conceptu, quem non alium videret quam alios, non aliter crederet natum esse quam caeteros.

 

Cujus enim similem cum universis advertit naturam, parem habere arbitratus est cum omnibus causam; nec intellexit a transgressionis vinculis liberum, quem ab infirmitate mortalitatis non invenit alienum. Verax namque misericordia Dei, cum ad reparandum humanum genus ineffabiliter ei multa suppeterent, hanc potissimum consulendi viam elegit, qua ad destruendum opus diaboli, non virtute uteretur potentiae, sed ratione justitiæ.

 

Nam superbia hostis antiqui non immerito sibi in omnes homines jus tyrannicum vindicabat, nec indebito dominatu premebat, quos a mandato Dei spontaneos in obsequium suæ voluntatis illexerat. Non itaque juste amitteret originalem humani generis servitutem, nisi de eo quod subegerat vinceretur. Quod ut fieret, sine virili semine conceptus est Christus ex virgine, quam non humanus coitus, sed Spiritus sanctus fecundavit.

 

Et cum in omnibus matribus non fiat sine peccati sorde conceptio, hæc inde purgationem traxit, unde concepit. Quo enim paterni seminis transfusio non pervenit, peccati se illic origo non miscuit. Inviolata virginitas concupiscentiam nescivit, substantiam ministravit. [Assumpta est de matre Domini, natura, non culpa.] Creata est forma servi sine conditione servili, quia novus homo sic contemperatus est veteri, ut et veritatem susciperet generis, et vitium excluderet vetustatis.

 

English Translation :

 

Chapter III.

 

This very thing, then, beloved, that Christ chose to be born of a Virgin — does it not appear to have been of the highest wisdom? namely, so that, the one born being hidden, the devil might not know the salvation for the human race, and, with the spiritual conception concealed, who would see no one different from the others, would not believe him to have been born otherwise than the rest.

 

For when he perceived a nature like all others, he judged that it had an equal claim with all to be a cause; nor did he perceive him free from the bonds of transgression, whom he did not find alien to the weakness of mortality. For the true mercy of God, since many things were ineffably at hand for him to repair the human race, chose above all this way of comforting, whereby, to destroy the work of the devil, he would not make use of the force of power, but of the reason of justice.

 

For the pride of the ancient enemy was not without reason claiming for itself a tyrannical right over all men, and was oppressing with an undue dominion those whom it had drawn away from the command of God into the obedience of its own will. It would therefore not rightly lose the original servitude of the human race unless it were overcome in that which it had subjected. That this might happen, Christ was conceived from a virgin without male seed, whom not by human intercourse but the Holy Spirit fertilized.

 

And since in all mothers conception does not take place without the stain of sin, this one drew purification from the source from which she conceived. For because the infusion of paternal seed did not reach there, the origin of sin did not mingle itself in that place. Unviolated virginity knew not concupiscence; it ministered substance. [he assumed from the Mother of the Lord nature, not guilt.] The form of a servant was created without a servile condition, because the new man was so tempered with the old that he might both receive the truth of the race and exclude the vice of the former.

 

 

Further Reading:


Answering Joe Heschmeyer's Deceptive Abuse of Mary Being the New Eve to Support Roman Catholic Mariology

Blog Archive